It can be difficult to understand how to prepare your sequence data for input to an LSTM model.
Often there is confusion around how to define the input layer for the LSTM model.
There is also confusion about how to convert your sequence data that may be a 1D or 2D matrix of numbers to the required 3D format of the LSTM input layer.
In this tutorial, you will discover how to define the input layer to LSTM models and how to reshape your loaded input data for LSTM models.
After completing this tutorial, you will know:
How to define an LSTM input layer.
How to reshape a one-dimensional sequence data for an LSTM model and define the input layer.
How to reshape multiple parallel series data for an LSTM model and define the input layer.
How to Reshape Input for Long Short-Term Memory Networks in Keras Photo by Global Landscapes Forum, some rights reserved.
Tutorial Overview
This tutorial is divided into 4 parts; they are:
LSTM Input Layer
Example of LSTM with Single Input Sample
Example of LSTM with Multiple Input Features
Tips for LSTM Input
LSTM Input Layer
The LSTM input layer is specified by the “input_shape” argument on the first hidden layer of the network.
This can make things confusing for beginners.
For example, below is an example of a network with one hidden LSTM layer and one Dense output layer.
1
2
3
model=Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(32))
model.add(Dense(1))
In this example, the LSTM() layer must specify the shape of the input.
The input to every LSTM layer must be three-dimensional.
The three dimensions of this input are:
Samples. One sequence is one sample. A batch is comprised of one or more samples.
Time Steps. One time step is one point of observation in the sample.
Features. One feature is one observation at a time step.
This means that the input layer expects a 3D array of data when fitting the model and when making predictions, even if specific dimensions of the array contain a single value, e.g. one sample or one feature.
When defining the input layer of your LSTM network, the network assumes you have 1 or more samples and requires that you specify the number of time steps and the number of features. You can do this by specifying a tuple to the “input_shape” argument.
For example, the model below defines an input layer that expects 1 or more samples, 50 time steps, and 2 features.
1
2
3
model=Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(32,input_shape=(50,2)))
model.add(Dense(1))
Now that we know how to define an LSTM input layer and the expectations of 3D inputs, let’s look at some examples of how we can prepare our data for the LSTM.
Example of LSTM With Single Input Sample
Consider the case where you have one sequence of multiple time steps and one feature.
For example, this could be a sequence of 10 values:
1
0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, 1.0
We can define this sequence of numbers as a NumPy array.
We can then use the reshape() function on the NumPy array to reshape this one-dimensional array into a three-dimensional array with 1 sample, 10 time steps, and 1 feature at each time step.
The reshape() function when called on an array takes one argument which is a tuple defining the new shape of the array. We cannot pass in any tuple of numbers; the reshape must evenly reorganize the data in the array.
1
data=data.reshape((1,10,1))
Once reshaped, we can print the new shape of the array.
1
print(data.shape)
Putting all of this together, the complete example is listed below.
It provides self-study tutorials on topics like: CNN LSTMs, Encoder-Decoder LSTMs, generative models, data preparation, making predictions and much more...
Finally Bring LSTM Recurrent Neural Networks to
Your Sequence Predictions Projects
Thanks a lot for your explanations .
I have a confusion below:
Assuming that we have multiple parallel series as input for out model.The first step is to define these data as a matrix of M columns with N rows.To be 3D(samples, time steps, and features),is this means that,samples :1 sample ,time steps: row numbers of the matrix ,and features: column numbers of the matrix ? Must it be like this?Looking forward to your reply.Thank you
If you have parallel time series, then each series would need the same number of time steps and be represented as a separate feature (e.g. observation at a time).
Hi Yuan,
I got your question. You have doubt that can we say the number of rows is the time steps and number of columns is features. Yes you can understand this way also.
That is , sample, time steps and features is equivalent to sample, number of rows, number of columns respectively.
Hello Sir,
I have used your multivariates code for testing lstm model.Its working fine but I did not understand why lstm one row is hidden from train as well as test dataset. If I test two rows in test then got one prediction as a output. And datetime output this one prediction result?
hi jason,your artical is very inspire.
Now i am working with loan risk control. i have client repayment time difference for each period. i am working on use time series modle on time difference before to predite the client will overdue.
suppose i have 10000 client and for each client i have 6 period repayment time difference. as the artical you write my input data orginal is (10000*6).before i send it to LSTM model i should reshape it to 10000*6*1 3D dataset? is that the right way to do it? if you have any other experience of this problem you can tell me as well.
HI, I think wanghy wants to make a loan risk forecast.
The customer should pay 6 repayments for each loan.
So if you use [10000,6,1] to train the model,
how do you feed data when making prediction after 3 replayments have done
thanks jason
I am still confused about the timesteps.
Suppose the customer pays 240 repayments for each loan (20 years) and the loan risk is related to the latest year’s repayments.
So, the train data should be [rows, 12, 1] instead of [rows, 240, 1], right?
Sometimes, the values of timesteps and features are very large, such as 1024, 512.
How to choose the value of the timesteps when the memory is not enough?
sir i am working on prediction problem , i have an experimental data in 1D colunm for 8000 elements and also 3D data distributed alonh spatial coordinates like [x y z value]. now i have confusion how i use my 1D data and then 3D data for prediction.
thanks a lot for all the explanations you gave!
I tried to understand the effect of the reshape parameters and the effect in the spyder/variable explorer. But I do not understand the result shown in the data window.
I used the code from a different tutorial:
When checking the result in the variable explorer of spyder I see 3 dimensions of the array but can not connect it to the paramters sample, timestep, feature.
On axis 0 of data_re I see the complete dataset
On axis 1 of the data_re I get 0.1 and 1.0 in column 1
On axis 2 of the data_re I see the column 1 of axis 0 transposed to row 1
Thanks so much for the article (and the whole series in fact!). The documentation in Keras is not very clear on many things on its own.
I have been trying to implement a model that receives multiple samples of multivariate timeseries as input. The twist is that the length of the series, i.e. the “time steps” dimension is different for different samples. I have tried to train a model on each sample individually and then merge, (but then each LSTM is going to be extremely prone to overfitting). Another idea was to scale the samples to have the same time steps but this comes with a scaling factor of time steps for each sample which is not ideal either.
Is there a way to provide the LSTM with samples of dynamic time steps? maybe using a lower-level API?
HI Jason,
Thank you for this amazing article.
I have the same problem here. which is the samples have many different lengths.
I did not get the idea you said.
“A way I use often is to pad all sequences to the same length and use a masking layer on the front end to ignore masked time steps.”
can you please provide more details about that?
or maybe provide articles explain how to solve this problem.
Thanks very much for your tutorials on LSTM. I am trying to predict one time series from 10 different parallel time series. All of them are different 1D series. So, the shape of my X_train is (50000,10) and Y_train is (50000,1). I couldn’t figure out how to reshape my dataset and the input shape of LSTM if I want to use let’s say 100 time steps or look back as 100.
Respected Sir
I want to use LSTM RNN GRU to check changes in facial expression of the person who is watching a movie. Want to check his mental state whether he is a boar or interested to continue this movie or at what time he is a boar. Can you please help me how can I start to work on same.
Hi Jason,
I finally understood the input shape requirements.
Just a quick question: batch_size would be a certain number of samples inside a group e.g if we have 100 samples we can divide it into batches of 10. Batching helps with a faster training time right?
About sample (the first argument in reshape): if I have two sequences with different number of values (let’s suppose one with 10 values and another with 8) and want them to be considered as two distinct samples (not 2 features), a zero-padding is necessary?
Thanks a lot for the tutorial!
I am trying to understand the input shape for LSTM data (No. of timesteps & no. of features). Could I ask what each will be in the context of the iris dataset, please?
Am I correct to say that in the iris dataset, the timesteps can be 2, 3, 5, 6 – as long as it neatly divides the dataset into equal number of rows (iris has 150 rows).
And the number of features will be the number of columns (apart from the target column/class)?
First of all, thank you very much for your posts, I have learned a lot.
My question is because I’m not sure how to focus the next type of problems: multiples sequences of multiple features.
For example, predict the amount that a user could spend given the previous purchases (here I can consider different features such as the previous amounts, products, day of week, etc.). If I have a dataset with data of 1000 users and I want to predict the amount for each user, how should be addressed?
Can I use a lstm for all users or each user will have a model/lstm?
I understand that a lstm for all users could see things more interesting.. But I don’t know how to organize the input of different users.. because the example of two sequences (1,10,2) I don’t know how to apply.. I want to include more features for each sequence..
I think I’ve two ways: one with DL Model (LSTM maybe) but I’m not sure how to organize trainig set. The other way could be by grouping features by userid and apply the cuount of the category feature (previos on_hot_encode) and apply Descition Trees model
The first three columns are the key. We have 50000 products in 20 stores and I would like to predict the quantity (per product per store) at least 14 days ahead with LSTM.
What is the good start for the 3D input?
I am wondering if creating new features from date (as there are repetition), like day of week, day of month, month of year, etc. + the existing features + quantity (t), quantity (t+1) would do…
Thank you so much for the great amount of tutorials on LSTMs
Im trying to build an LSTM in keras using your examples and keep running into shape issues.
I have time series data set with prices for different things, and am trying to predict the price of item4 for time t+1
Item4 is a lagged value so that you can use previous set of prices to predict the next.
The data set has 400 sequential observations.
since the data variable has uniform interval of observations and none are missing, i am dropping the datetime variable.
So now i have 4 variables and 400 observations.
trainX = train[:, 0:-1] #use first 3 variables
trainY = train[:,-1] #use the last variable
so now the trainX data set has price1 price2 and price3 variables (its my undestanding that this means there are 3 “feautres” in keras)
trainY is the predictor data set and only cointains item4_price
trainX = numpy.reshape(trainX, (1, 400, 3)) #reshape, this means there is 1 sample, 400 timestamps, and 3 features
Keep getting various shape errors all the time, no matter what i do. I tried switching it around, and even ommiting the first dimension.
I was wondering if you could point me in the right dirrection of what it is that i keep missing in my understnading of keras/lstm shapes.
I also dont know if the trainY set needs shaping? I tried to shape it too but python was also not happy with that.
I have previously read that tutorial and feel as though i understand it fine.
But when applying what I learned to the problem in a way as described previously, find that Im running into some trouble.
So i was hoping I was just overlooking something, but at this point im not really sure what. Is what Im doing seem reasonable?
I’m trying to understand the input_shape but I think I’m totally confused about the time step variable. I have a multivariate time series with 18,000 samples and 720 features. I created a 10 lagged observation dataset to forecast the next 5 time steps so my dataset goes from t-10 to t+5, being the feature dataset from t-10 to t and the label dataset from t+1 to t+5.
Assuming that I take 15,000 samples for training, what will be the values of the reshape function? I think it should be [15000, 1, 7200 (720 features * 10)]. Regarding the time step, is the value “1” correct or it should be the number of lagged observations, that is, 10?
Hi Jason!
Thank you so much for all the tutorials on LSTMs, I’ve learned a lot.
I’m trying to implement the LSTM Architecture from the paper “Dropout improves Recurrent Neural Networks for Handwriting Recognition” for resolving the handwritten recognition problem.
Basically I have to train the network giving in input variable-sized images (different W and H but always 3 channels) and to predict what is the word written in the image. What I can’t understand is how to deal with variable sized images? Can I consider images as some sequences (for ex. a 50×30 image considered as 50 sequences with 30 features?). The authors say I give in input a block of image of size 2×2 scaning in 4 different directions (multidirectional multidimensional LSTM).
What do I have to specify here : input_size(Samples,Time Steps,Features) ? The Samples refers to the number of all images I have in training set or the number of miniblocks 2×2 ? What about time steps and features? I don’t get it and its very confusing. Can you please help with any idea? I am new in this area and Im stacked in this problem.
Hi Jason!
Thanks so much for your tutorials on LSTM!
I’m trying to predict trajectory with LSTM and ARIMA now. After reading this tutorial, I’ve got some questions.
(1) Do we must transfer time series to lag observations if we want to do forecast work with LSTM?
(2) After transfering time series to supervised learning problems, the forecast is only related to “order” or “lag” rather than “time”(like ARIMA do)? Why the input is not time/date? And the time interval of data must be even?
Thanks a lot in advance!
The order of the observations is sufficient for the model, if the time steps are consistently spaced it does not need the absolute date/time information.
Hello Jason! Congratulations on the LSTM input tutorial!
Could you please answer three questions?
I’m working with 500 samples that have varying sizes. My doubts are related to the organization of these 500 samples within this 3-dimensional input, mainly in relation to the Samples dimension.
The dimension “Features” has already defined that it will have size 26, the dimension “Time Steps” will have to have size 100 but the dimension “Samples” is that I still do not know what its value will be.
Doubt 1: In these cases of samples with different sizes to know the dimension “Samples” I have to be based on the larger sample and for the other samples I fill in the value 0 (zero) in the additional spaces?
Doubt 2: Can I have more than one line in the “Samples” dimension representing the same sample?
Doubt 3: How do samples have varying sizes, there are possibilities to work with 4 dimensions, for example: “Samples” x “Part of Samples” x “Time Steps” x “Features”?
Thank you for such a good tutorial! This really helps!
I am not sure if I understand the model correctly:
The sequence of samples does matter in lstm because the state of current one is affected by last one in the sequence.
If this is the case, can you let me know how I should deal with the following scenarios?
I have non-equally spaced trajectory data. The interval varies from seconds to days. Solutions I come up with are interpolation or adding time feature. What do you think is a good way to prepare the data?
Assuming last problem is solved, how can I organize the input if my data contains trajectories of different people? For example, trajectory of one person is (100, 5, 2) and trajectory of another one is (200, 5, 2). How to train both sequence in one model?
If each trajectory is a sample, and samples are independent, then perhaps use a batch size of 1 or reset at the end of each sample. Compare the skill of this model to one that does not reset state so often.
Hello Jason, you are making a good job Dr.! I am a bit confused about my data shape for the network: I have 300 different samples, where the next one always is measured lets say in 1 min steps, so I have in total 300 timesteps, and each file is containing 1 column, 2.000 rows. When we say I want to reduce the ‘features’, rows I am thinking that my inputshape must be therefore (1,300,2000) and than I can reduce to something e.g.200. with the lstm decoder ?
Sorrry for the obscurity, 1 sample has 2000 rows all in one column so only one type of value temperature is measured. in total I have 300 samples and time distance between their recording is 1 min
I think if I understood you right, the 2000 rows are related to one measurement (so I measure in 1 second 2000 times the temperature). But when you regard it with an lstm autoencoder I try to reduce the “features” to learn from them and make than the prediction. I do not know the shape for the lstm encoder decoder either it should be (1, 300,2000) or (2000,300,1) but for the last one I got strange results, the first one is closer to the real data. Which one is right ?
The input to the encoder will be [300, ?, 2000] where ? represents the number of time steps you wish to model.
The encoder decoder is not appropriate for all sequence prediction problems, it is suited to sequence output that differs in length to the input. If you are doing straight sequence classification/regression it might not be appropriate.
HI Jason, the example is really good. Besides this I have a question for my data. I have temperature values measured for a sampling rate of 1 second with a sampling frequency of 10.000. So I measure in 1 second 10.000 different values but same unit(lets say force). This I repeat with certain time intervals. Do I have than 10.000 different features or only one feature as input dimension ?
great tutorial jason .. but i have a problem in the reshaping my RNN model,,
this my code
import numpy as np
from keras.datasets import imdb
from keras.models import Sequential
from keras.layers import Dense
from keras.layers import LSTM
from keras.layers import Bidirectional
from keras.preprocessing import sequence
# fix random seed for reproducibility
np.random.seed(7)
train = np.loadtxt(“featwithsignalsTRAIN.txt”, delimiter=”,”)
test = np.loadtxt(“featwithsignalsTEST.txt”, delimiter=”,”)
Thank you for the great tutorial. It helps me to predict time series data sequences with the lstm model.
However, I have a question about how to determine the length of look_back time steps.
For example, there is a time series sequence X1, X2, X3, …, Xn. When I apply ARIMA for prediction Xn+1, I can use ACF and PCF to determine the parameter pi and qi. The number of pi indicates the look_back time steps. Then, the ARIMA equation can be used to predict Xn+1.
But for lstm, I do not know how to determine the look_back time steps, in other words, the reshape size for a time series sequence. Is there any way to get an appropriate look_back time steps in reshaping the time series sequence data for lstm? Could you pls give me some suggestions about it?
I am still confused about your suggestion. Do you mean that I need plot the ACF/PACF to find the number of time lag for applying lstm?
I do not think the the ACF/PACF can be used for determining the look_back time steps for lstm. These two criteria explain the linear correlation of time series.
For those nonlinear correlation time series sequences, the ACF/PACF is not truncating or tailing and ARIMA cannot be used to model them.
Then I use lstm to model the nonlinear correlation time series sequences and lstm is good at it. Unfortunately, the ACF/PACF is not able to find the time lag in applying lstm.
Before applying lstm for a time series prediction, I must decide the reshape size. However, I cannot find any information on the internet about how to determine it. Is there any book or tutorial can help me to solve this problem?
Thanks for the article and clarifying the dimensions which some of us have trouble with them.
However, my question goes to something I didn’t find anybody asked in the Q&A:
Why do you put 32 units in the input LSTM layer?
I mean, if you have 2 features in each of the 10 time steps and one sample example, why would we want to have more than 10 neurons in the first input layer?
As I understand LSTMs, each neuron gets feed with the features of one specific time step (in the cell images of colah’s blog it is stated as Xt, as you will surely know).
If you feed the first one with “t” and continue like “t+1,t+2,t+3…t+10”, what time step will we use in the case of t+17 for example which would be the 17th neuron?
In fully connected ANN the first input layer has the same number of neurons that of features. Is there anything I’m missing or is there any rule to select the number of neurons if we choose that our input layer is a LSTMs one?
Thanks for the attention and for correcting any error that I may be not understanding.
So, as you say, if the units in the input LSTM layer (I am supposing that it is the first layer we use) are not related to the time steps, each time we feed a batch of data into that layer through “Xt” we will feed one row (one sample) of those 300 with 10 columns and we will do it two times: one for the first feature and another for the second feature, and the important point, this feeding will be to every unit of those 32 that compose the LSTM layer. Am I getting the point?
I get confused because in normal feedforward ANN, the first layer (the input layer) has as many nodes as features we have, so that we can feed each feature in one node.
If you could clarify this for me, you would be doing me a big favour because there is not much insight about this details elsewhere.
Hey Jason,
i think i have the same question as Eriz had but i’m not sure whether i understood his explanation right, so i would be great if you could tell me if i got it right.
So the question is: How is the data fed into the first layer of a lstm/rnn ? (i hope there aren’t any differences)
Let’s take Eriz example: 32 Units in the first layer and an input shape of (300,10,2)
I understood Eriz like this:
For one example e (from the 300 examples) all 32 units in the first layer get the time series with length 10 of example e. And this seperately for each feature one after the other (in this case two times) before the network processes the next example.
Is this correct?
Also if we look at this typical illustration of a rnn: http://www.wildml.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/rnn.jpg
Am i right that in this case the variable t in the image would be in the range of 1 <= x <= 10 ? (because of the length of the time series)
Thank you very much in advance, because i couldn't find any detailed description on how this works.
Each of the 32 units in the hidden layer are separate and do not interact.
For a given unit, it receives one time step of data at a time with 2 features. This continues until all 10 time steps have been shown, the final activation is then passed on to the next layer.
Somewhat. I now understand what happens for a single unit.
You said that all units are independent. Does that mean each of the units recieves the same data (the complete time series of an example) in the way you described in your second sentence?
Hi Jason, thank you for the articles and books… I just have some open questions about shape. Since I have a 2D multivariate data ex: (samples = 1024, features = 6) , and make a supervised learning dataset with ten (10) lags, the shape will be (samples = 1024, features = 60).
The question is: The shape for LSTM is (samples, timesteps, features) so it will be data.reshape(1024, 10, 60) ? I dont, understand why some tutorials use something lile (1, 10, 1) and how to reshape/split train/test on the new shape. The steps are:
1 – convert to supervised problem.
2 – reshape the entire 2D dataset or split here and reshape after?
3 – how about shape of Y to make predictions?
I just need a step with these key points… Thanks for the excelent posts.
Hi again Jason, thanks for the reply. On your example for one and multiple features, you say:
– consider a matrix of 2 columns with 10 rows, This data can be framed as 1 sample with 10 timesteps and 2 features.
So, this “1 sample” is drive me crazy. When I have a 2D data like lines vs columns (sample, features), I thought the number of samples will be the number of lines of a matrix 2D data; So it always be (sample, features) –> (sample, timesteps, features). On your example, the rows turned into timesteps and I can’t realize this sample = 1 in this post. Why one sample? Why rows become timesteps here and become samples on other examples?
Another question is: After rechape input data, how to reshape X_train, y_train and new data for predictions.
Hi Thank you so much for this article, it helped me understand Keras and Overall Input thing.
I am really confused how can I prepare the output data. Overall the output
Thanks for sharing. I am confused about the padding and “sliding window” method. Suppose the dataset contains two sequences s1,s2 and time_step is set to 3, then s1=(1,2,3,4,5) should have 2 subsequences: [(1,2,3), (2,3,4)], s2=(6,7,8,9,10,11,12) should have 4 subsequences: [(6,7,8), (7,8,9), (8,9,10), (9,10,11)]. Theses 6 subsequences have the same length equal to time_step, so it can be reshaped to 3D tensor (6, 3, 1) without padding s1 and s2 into same length. If all the sequences length are greater than the time_step, then we don’t need to pad the sequences into same length. Am I right?
Say I have a normalized 2D array data with a shape of (10,2)
but when I want to reshape the data to a 3D array of (10,3,2), I got an error saying:
“ValueError: cannot reshape array of size 20 into shape (10,3,2)”
It seems that the previous 2D array multiply the samples of data of 10 with the input dimensions of 2 before reshaping it to a 3D array, and perhaps that caused the error?
You need more data to go from (10,2) to (10,3,2), think about it, maybe even draw a pic of it. You are invention dimensions that don’t exist in your original data.
If you may I Have a Question : I Have 20 Topics (classes) each topic have 700 files each file is a represent a document but in word embedding representation (size of each file : number of words X 300 features ) I want to train a LSTM Network is it possible and how ?
I have another question please, so for my problem does your book “Deep Learning for Natural Language Processing” have LSTM in it because I don’t only want to take the word embedding only but I want to take word’s order in consideration .
or I’ll need your book “Long Short-Term Memory Networks With Python” also ?
Sorry for bothering you with my questions but I’m really stuck and I don’t have anyone who can help me in this matter.
I have a question regarding the input shape which I cannot find a solid answer to. I don’t know how much this question is related to this blog post, but would appreciate to hear your answer to my question:
I have a training set which contains sequences of images (say n is the number of the images in the sequence and c, h, w are channel , height, and width). I have trained a CNN-LSTM on that with the input shape of (n,c,h,w).
Now, for predicting through this network, it seems I have to feed sequences of data to it at each time (not a single frame). That is, with each new frame I need to update the sequence and feed it to the network to get the results.
However, I was under the impression that when dealing with RNN or LSTM, we can feed one frame at a time (because of recurrency), rather than feeding the whole sequence. Was this impression wrong?
So, briefly, when having an LSTM network for real time prediction, do we need to feed sequences to the network, or are there cases that we may feed a single signal/frame/datapoint?
Thanks! I went through your other blog post before (and now again). But still I don’t see how I can feed one frame at a time. How about the input size?
Do you mean I can have a CNN and a seperate LSTM. Feed frames one at a time to CNN and then in a sequence to LSTM? This means, again, I have to create the sequence myself to feed to the network?
What I don’t understand is that the input-shape of the trained network is defined to be (n, c, h, w), how can I feed an input of shape (1,c,h,w) when n is not 1?
No, it is one model. The size to the CNN is the size of one image. Images are exposed to the model in a sequence, something like:
[samples, frames, width, height, channels]
I created a model before to read your post, and I see that I made a mistake. I swapped time step by feature. How much this can impact in model performance?
One thing I did’t understand on LSTM network-
If the output of each time step suppose to predict the next input,
how come that the input vector dimension (witch related to the features number) not equal to output vector dimension (witch related to the number of units in the layer)
I would just like to run my problem through with you just to verify you feel the approach outlined in this tutorial is suitable for me:
I have two columns of data – one is resonance energies and the other is corresponding neutron widths. I want to feed 70% of this data to the network i.e values of resonance energies and neutron neutrons. Then ask the network to predict the neutron width values given the remaining 30% unseen resonance energies.
I wanted an LSTM layer as it may help use previous computations in its current prediction.
So I believe I have 2 inputs and one output.
If i have 300 values of [resonance energies, neutron widths] (i.e 300 rows of data) would my reshape be:
reshape(1, 300, 2) or reshape(1, 300, 1) ? I’m not sure if the second column is technically a feature as its meant to be the output.
Also would i need any explicit pairing given each resonance energy is related to the neutron width on the same row? Or should i use some key-value pair?
(This is also the first experiment, I also hope to then use resonance energy and neutron width to predict another variable but essentially in exactly the same way as described in this problem just the new experiment contains one more feature)
I have read the link you provided however I am unclear as to whether my data allows me to drop the time variable as mentioned in your article. If so, I could perhaps have the sample of [1,300,1] as opposed to [1,300,2]
One query I have is I’m getting a score of ‘Test Score: 0.00 MSE (0.01 RMSE)” for my test set (which is 30% of my samples) would not having enough samples really be shown by such low RMSE scores? If anything doesn’t that show the predictions are almost too good (or overfitting)?
Sorry one final thing from reading this tutorial – If one uses an LSTM layer, is it still possible to use look_back? (an argument used quite frequently in your other tutorials when creating a dataset). If I am correct, an LSTM layer essentially allows for previous calculations to be examined when determining the current calculation, but look_back determines how many previous timesteps can be consider at each timestep calculation?
I do not have the capacity to shape the data for you. I believe you have everything you need to shape your data for an LSTM model.
A look-back refers to the number of prior time steps of data to feed to the model in one sample. E.g. the “timesteps” in [samples, timesteps, features].
so the first line simply creates the numpy matrix like dataset,
but does the second line fill it with nan values? (if so why, or is it just a check?)
The third line then shift the test predict plot?
Hi Jason,
Thank you for this post. I’ve learned a lot from it.
I have a question about my LSTM model for classification.
My input data is 4842 samples, 34 time steps, 254 features. In other words, it’s (4842,34,254).
I have trained it with proper parameters. Although I got a decent result with 98% accuracy on validation data, I got pretty low accuracy at around 20% on test data (from separate data).
My first thought is overfitting but I also tried callback function such as earlystopping or reducelronplateau. It does not give me a better result.
Could you give me any suggestions on this issue?
I learn a lot from your blog posts. For this specific post, I have three specific questions.
Q1: How do we decide the value of FIRST parameter of the constructor LSTM. You used LSTM (32, …). How was that value of 32 decided for the representative problem that is being addressed here? For word embedding input, is a vlaue between 200 and 500 reasonable?
Q3: What is the significane of this parameter? Is it number of LSTM cells and should it be matched with the value of dimension of input layer of the Keras model (in case of work embedding, value b/w 200 and 500)?
Q3: What would be perfformance impact of choosing a value of 500 for this parameter?
I just don’t understand reshape. I do not see how you calculate the array and enter it to batch size or train data on it. I have been stuck on this all day and googling. Any help from anyone is greatly appreciated
I have multidimensional timeseries data with a sample size of 200,000 and 50 dimensions.
I want to train a sequence to sequence autoencoder on normal data to use it later to detect anomalies. I want to have a go at this task using a LSTM autoencoder, using the example from the keras site:
I am confused about how to convert my data.
When generating the sequences lets say with a timestep of 100: do I convert this 200k data into separate sequences of 100, or use a sliding window to generate my sequences?
Hi Jason,
Excellent tutorial. I have a question that I wanted to ask.
I have a total of 3 sequences.
Sequence 1: It has a shape of 800×2500 (800 observations and 2500 features) It falls into category 1
Sequence 2: It has a shape of 1000×2500. It falls into category 2
Sequence 3: It has a shape of 600×2500. It falls into category 3.
I have combined these 3 sequences into 1 array which has 2400×2500 features. I want to train an LSTM network on this array. Want it to learn pattern of these sequences and predict the category (1,2 r 3) given a new test sequence of any length (? x 2500) shape.
What should my input shape be? Should it be (1,2400,2500)?
I am trying to understand data inputs to LSTM autoencoder, but I am lost.
I want use autoencoder for anomaly detection in time series (falling detection).
Dataset:
500 samples (data from gyroscope – walking, jumping, running…)
600-10000 time steps in each sample (6-100seconds).
3 features.
Example of one sample(one file):
time x y z
1 1.3 9.6 1.3
2 1.2 9.3 1.5
3 0.9 8.0 -2
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
1000 1.4 9.8 2
Idea:
Train autoencoder to reproduce normal data(walking,jumping,running…).
Anomaly detection: Reproduction error.
I want to check anomaly (fall) in 2second time windows(200 time steps) -> Reproduce every 2second window and check reproduction error.
Questions:
Can you please explain how to prepare dataset for this task?(dimensions, structure of dataset…)
How big batches and time steps(seq_length) shoud I use?
Should I generate batches randomly, or from start of dataset? (batch1: 0 – batch_size, batch2: batch_size-batch_size*2 …) -> I saw that someone generated random batches in every iteration. Couldn’t that cause some data to be used multiple times and others is not used at all?
Hello, thanks a lot for this tutorial. I’m working on some project but still stuck after reading this. Here’s the description
I have a dataframe of 2 columns, both text – one is title and other is the label to it.
Unique label count is around 40k so one hot encode was out of question.
I used word2vec with size=150 for both, trained and used the created model to encode both title and label.
e.g. for hello world
I split them and then use their respective word vectors of size 150, add them and normalize to create a vector that represents hello world.
So both columns in my dataframe had been changed and each column of each row has a vector.
dataframe.shape shows (len, 2) where len is length of dataframe
and then I did
I am trying to feed 3 column(3316 rows) merged encoded text Train_data and Train_Labels categorizing class 1-9(3316 rows) to an lstm network.
Train_input last column is output of word embedded vector of 50 dimensions,(3316,50)
Train_input first and second columns are words – one-hot encoded text data (3316,2)
After merging three columns the shape is (samples=1, time_steps=3316, features=3)
TraIN_LABELS categorizing above train_data into class 1-9. encoded it using label encoder.
train_input=(1,3316,3), train_label=(1,3316,9) facing error with this data shape
LSTM network returned error as “expecting dense 3dimensional shape instead recieved
(3316,)” when given 1D array.
Is there any other way that i can feed? Have i done any mistake in reshaping train data?
Really appreciated your explanation!
Could you explain how to feed multi-input the LSTM, let’s say:
you have: data = data.reshape(1, 10, 2)
data = array([
[0.1, 1.0],
[0.2, 0.9],
[0.3, 0.8],
[0.4, 0.7],
[0.5, 0.6],
[0.6, 0.5],
[0.7, 0.4],
[0.8, 0.3],
[0.9, 0.2],
[1.0, 0.1]])
and model.add(LSTM(32, input_shape=(10, 2)))
So in1 iteration of epoch, the value in the first column: 0.1,0.2,….. 1.0 will be fed into xt, xt+1,…, xt+9 of input gate of LSTM. And the 2nd column: 1.0, 0.9…0.1, will they be also fed into xt,xt+1,…,xt+9 or they will fed into another input gate of LSTM: xxt, xxt+1,….,xxt+9 ?
I am really confused with Input shape. Assume I have a data set of some info about houses.
Features are [size, room_no, floor_no]
My data set contains 4 samples as follow:
dataX = [[200, 3, 1], [150, 1, 1], [270, 4, 2], [320, 3, 2]]. Which for example dataX[0] is house number0 with size of 200, 3 rooms and 1 floor.
Now I want to train my LSTM. Are (samples, time_step, feature) different from the ones I defined here? I mean I have 4 samples with 3 features! How do you tell that to LSTM? For example would you please say that in the first 2 or 3 time steps what data is fed into LSTM?
Each of size, rooms and floor are “features”. Features=3
If you have 3 houses, these are “samples”. Samples=3
But you did not mention any time steps. If you have no time steps (observations over time), an LSTM is a poor choice and I would recommend an MLP instead.
First of all, thanks for all your work. It is grateful to have a support like you give us in all your tutorials!
On the other hand, I have a question. For LSTMs we need a 3D array (samples, features, timesteps). But I still don’t understand what “timesteps” means? Is it the same of loop_back variable?
Like others, I wanna say thank you for this and other useful articles.
I need to connect output of ConvLSTM2D to a LSTM!
The output of ConvLSTM2D is (samples, time, output_row, output_col, filters) which return_sequences is True.
I’m confused here how this 5-D input can be feed to a LSTM!
I will be thankful if any help!
I have a dataframe of n,p rows (n for the different samples and p for q timesteps and r static feature p = q+r ). For each row, I have q values for the measure of interest and r static features.
Basically, I want to do a time series classification that is based also on the static features.
From what I understood, the input shape should be (n,q,r) but I cannot transform my dataframe from (n,p) to (n,q,r) since p = q+r
Dear Jason,
why do we need to reshape the data in numpy before feeding the data to the lstm. Why Keras doesn’t do it automatically?
if I have a sequence of 10 values and I want to predict the 11th value, I guess Keras LSTM has already all the information in a numpy array of size (1,10) to answer the task of predicting the 11th value . Why do I need to reshape it to (1,10,1) ?
Hi Jason,
Thank you for your great post.
I have problem about padding.
I use the pre-trained sentence embedding(dim:300),
and 1 sample means a document in my application.
Now I have variable sentence number in documents.
(Not sentence sequences with variable words length)
E.g., doc1:[sent1, sent2]
doc2:[sent1]
doc3:[sent1, sent2, sent3]
The zero-padding in variable sentence sequences means pad 0 after sequence of word_index
But pre-trained sentence embedding can’t map sentence to index
How do I pad the sentence number to a fixed size?
Does it just pad 300 zeros in each timestep, and use mask layer to skip those zeros?
E.g., pad_sent = np.zeros((1,300))
doc1:[sent1, sent2, pad_sent]
doc2:[sent1, pad_sent, pad_sent]
doc3:[sent1, sent2, sent3]
Hi Jason Hopefully you have not already answered this. To prep the x data for LSTM input,
the data is reshaped to a 3 d array. Should something similiar also be done to the y data? Should it also be divided up into subsequences so that the output is synced up with the input?
If so, should that be done prior to transforming the data with one hot encoding? Or does the
one hot encoding come after? Thanks for all your help.
great article – always come here when needed a boiled-down explanation. Thank you!
Regarding input shapes – have been using LSTM for a while and didn’t have any problems with it but now I tried 1D convolutional layers for speeding up processing and now I run into trouble – can you see what the problem is with the following? (Dummy data used here)
#load packages
import numpy as np
import pandas as pd
from keras.models import Sequential
from keras.layers import Dense, Dropout, Activation, GRU, TimeDistributed
from keras.layers import Conv1D, MaxPooling1D, Flatten, GlobalAveragePooling1D
from keras.layers import Conv2D, MaxPooling2D
from keras.utils import np_utils
#splitting matrix
#data
X = np.asarray([data[i*timeStep:(i + 1)*timeStep,:] for i in range(0,length * fs // timeStep)])
#classes
Y = np.asarray([classes[i*timeStep:(i + 1)*timeStep] for i in range(0,length * fs // timeStep)])
#split into training and test set
from sklearn.model_selection import train_test_split
trainX, testX, trainY, testY = train_test_split(X,Y,test_size=0.2,random_state=0)
#set up model with simple 1D convnet
model = Sequential()
model.add(Conv1D(8,10,activation=’relu’,input_shape=(timeStep,nfeat)))
model.add(MaxPooling1D(3))
model.add(Flatten())
model.add(Dense(10,activation=’tanh’))
model.add(Dense(2,activation=’softmax’))
model.summary()
#compile model
model.compile(loss=’mse’,optimizer=’Adam’ ,metrics=[‘accuracy’])
#train model
model.fit(trainX,trainY_OHC,epochs=5,batch_size=4,validation_split=0.2)
I get an error for the fitting:
ValueError: Error when checking target: expected dense_17 to have 2 dimensions, but got array with shape (400, 20, 2)
Thanks for the tutorial. Your tutorials are a life-saver! I have a simple doubt.
I have extracted speech features from 597 .wav files into arrays. Each array is of shape Nx40, where N varies between 500-1100. In other words, for each of the 597 .wav files, I have an array of N rows (varying between 500-1100) and 40 columns (40 acoustic features).
1. So, what should be my 3D input shape to the LSTM? Is it (1, ?, 40), where ? = N.
2. If it is (1, ?, 40), then should I pick a particular length and pad the rest of them?
Really stuck with this. Any response will be of immense help. Thanks!
Sounds like you have nearly 600 samples, 500-1100 time steps and about 40 features.
I’d recommend padding the time steps and having a shape of something like [600, 1100, 40] as a start, then try truncating time steps to see how it impacts the model.
Hey Jason,
I have a Time series dataset for 38,000 distinct patients, where each patient has 30 physiological parameters recorded for an hour. If I want to extract 48 hours of information of a patient for every hour, then technically I’ll have 48 rows for a single patient, every row containing observations for 30 feature for every hour! suppose I want to extract similar data for the other 29,000 patients, then ill end up with over a lakh rows i.e(29,000 * 48 rows). So should my input shape be (30,000, 48, 30) ?
What should be the output layer shape? Particularly, if I have only one sample, do I need to reshape it into three dimensions? For example, if I have the input data of shape [m,n] and output also has [m,n] shape. Do I need to change the input into [m,1,n] shape? Also, can I keep the output shape [m,n] if I am using return_sequences=False? I am dealing with time series data. Below are the input and output at different time steps for example
Input: Output:
[1,2] [3,4]
[2,3] [4,5]
[4,5] [6,7]
Thank you
Your article is so good. I want to apply this to my data set.
I have 3000 samples and 88 features(columns).In that number of feature columns, I have 20 features called A, B, C, D etc.For each one of them I have 3 columns A1,A2,A3 , B1,B2,B3 , C1,C2,C3 etc as lag columns. Thus 20+20*3 = 80 are the feature columns with lags
and 8 other features which do not have lag values.
How to convert that into a shape of 3D array to feed as input to LSTM model?
Your reply is greatly appreciated.
sir,
directly we are using LSTM function to process the data .instead we can write the code for input gate ,forget gate and output gate by creating own lstm function
But how should I present my data to use something with (2,10,2) or (3,10,2)? Is it an array of arrays?
Ultimately I want to be able to go from an hdf5 file to a numpy array to this 3d shape, but I’m struggling to tell my model that there is more than one sample, even when i’m just making up and typing the data as a toy example. Any tips?
I don’t think I explained it very well. Thanks for taking the time to reply. I think my question is what should my data look like if I have more than one sample and I’m trying to use reshape?
What I mean is at the moment ‘samples’ is a numpy array representing just one example of 2 features and 10 timesteps. when really, samples should be a dataset of many examples. And I don’t understand how to write that so that it can be reshaped. Should samples be a list of numpy arrays. or does it need to be an array of arrays or something else? I’ve tried both but neither seems to work.
If I want use temporal component for a LSTM, i think that my sequence, will be make by date_col.
But, If I select date_col, I will have a array of new information. I mean, it’s not a row typical secuence, I think this is more complex.
My secuence will be [day1,day2,day3] and, in each day, I have a array with [product1,product2,product3], and each product [feat1, feat2].
For day 1: [[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2]]
Secuence will be:
[ [[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2]],
[[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2]],
[[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2]] ]
This is correct? This will work with neural networks?
Hi Jason. Thank you for your informative articles. They have been very helpful to me.
I was wondering if you could give me your recommendation on setting up a LSTM model. I’m dealing with three features that are measured when a passive RFID tag is read by an RFID reader. I understand that before setting up my model, I need to decide how many time steps I will be dealing with for each input. Let’s say I set that number at 32 time steps. This means my input shape will be (32, 3). What I’m not clear on is if I need to add a feature for a time stamp of when that read occurred. Tag reads can happen at any rate. There could be one read per second which would mean my input instance of (32, 3) would span 32 seconds, or there could be one read per minute which would mean my input instance of (32, 3) would span 32 minutes. Most importantly, the read rate will not be constant. I could get 3 reads in 1 second and then wait 30 seconds for the fourth read to come in.
Does the LSTM need to know about this, or is it enough to simply give it the time ordered sequence of reads without it knowing the actual time span those 32 reads occurred over?
If I did have to add a time stamp to my data, the input shape would now be (32, 4). As a follow up question, does the LSTM require me to define a fixed time step between the feature inputs? What I mean is, am I forced to pick a time span of say 1 second between the input feature list? If I am, and I only have reads at time 0 seconds, 4 seconds, and 6 seconds, do I then have to generate my (32, 4) input values as follows:
(0, x0, y0, z0)
(1, missing, missing, missing)
(2, missing, missing, missing)
(3, missing, missing, missing)
(4, x4, y4, z4)
(5, missing, missing, missing)
(6, x6, y6, z6)
…..
OR
is there no assumption needed on the time between inputs so I can I simply stack them without inserting missing values, such as:
(0, x0, y0, z0)
(4, x4, y4, z4)
(6, x6, y6, z6)
Any input you can provide would be appreciated.
Thank you.
Thanks Jason. I was surprised to hear you say LSTM’s are terrible at time series. What I’m trying to implement is a binary sequence classification model using the setup I described above. If you think LSTM’s are not the right approach given what I’ve described, what type of model do you think would work best? I want to process the data as new reads come in and give a classification output every time I get a new read.
I was planning to use your post on: Sequence Classification with LSTM Recurrent Neural Networks in Python with Keras as my starting point, but now you’ve got me concerned I’m going down the wrong path.
Hi,Jason. I want add a dense layer before LSTM layer, but don’t know how to reshape the data. The input data (train_x) is 3D (batch_size,time_step,input_dim), I firstly want to reshape the data to 2D so as to apply to dense layer,.After operating the dense layer ,I have to reshape the 2D outcome of dense layer to 3D so as to apply in the LSTM layer. I am using keras function API, but I can not find a reshape layer to do that (keras.layers.reshape can not do that.).Do you have any idea?
Hi Jason, when you write: “How to reshape multiple parallel series data for an LSTM model and define the input layer”
Does this statement refer to text + tag data, for example text data with parallel IOB (inside – outside – begin) tags for named entity recognition? For example:
Alex I-PER
is O
going O
to O
Los B-LOC
Angeles I-LOC
If you are talking about something different in this article, do you have another article on preparing data for such parallel text sequences?
Hi Jason,
I’m kind of confused about the part of model.add(LSTM(32)). Does the number 32 represent 32 neurons? or more specifically, 32 memory cells for LSTM?
Hi Jason,
I am working on project for crime prediction. I have a dataset containning row as date(timestamp) and columns as area(features). Each cell contains count of crimes happened in particular area.
Total no of rows = 1825 days of crime counts per area or 5 years
here is the dataset.
I want to use sliding window to forecast which will take 100 days as input and predict
101th day output i.e. crime count for each area.
Here, I wiil consider first 3 rows(0-2) as input and predict output i.e. 4th row(3)
I will be shifting dataframe by -3
Questions:
1) what is X_train shape, y_train shape?
(1,1825,4)
here samples = 1(?), timesteps = 1825 rows, features = 4 columns
Am I correct?
What is exactly sample?
Hello Jason, thanks for your tutorial,
I have a question, I have a Time series dataset for about 38.000 patients, where each patient has 38 physiological parameters recorded for one hour, and each patient has at least 25 hours of parameters recorded, for clarification:
pat1: feat1, feat2, ….. feat38, hour1, label
feat1, feat2, ….. feat38, hour2, label
………………………………,hour25, label
pat2: feat1, feat2, ….. feat38, hour1, label
feat1, feat2, …., feat38, hour2, label
………………………………,hour25, label
…….
pat38000: ….
The model should predict whether the patient has the disease or not, as early as possible.
My question is how I would shape my input array? I do not understand what the samples will be
(Samples, time-step, features) -> (?, 7 hours “for example” ?, 38) or what?
Hi Jason, can you please help me with reshaping data for LSTM,
I have data set with shape (4615, 9), 4618 inputs, 9 features and 3 classes (labels) to predict.
I want to reshape my data so the input shape have 5 time steps. I try to do it in this way
X = np.reshape(X, (923,5,X_train.shape[1]))
but I have got an error when try to train_test_split.
I only can make it work with one time step X_test = np.reshape(X_test, (X_test.shape[0],1,X_test.shape[1]))
🙁
Thanks for your tutorials. I’m trying to build a hydrological model that can predict streamflow with a sample lead time of 10 days, though I’m confused as to how to shape the data. First, I assume I’d shift the x and y data to reflect the lag and end up with 355 (365-10) samples of each. Say I have 4 features – the base shape for x would be would be (355, 4). Does 355 represent the number of samples or the number of time steps? They seem as they are the same to me, though I think I need to reshape the data to either (1, 355, 4) or (355,1, 4). Or perhaps (5, 355/5, 1) – etc. Or, do I need to generate separate lagged (by 1) sequences to generate something like (100, 355, 4)?
Do you have examples/suggestions how to use contemporaneous conditional context for time series prediction using LSTM and/or CNN (e.g. predicting next week product sales based on given price that week and history of sales and prices). The differences from multivariate prediction is that conditional context is known for the prediction week. Thanks!
Sir if I use LSTMs(Encoder Decoder model) for summarizing articles , I’ll input the sentence vector , encoder encodes them to fixed sized vectors , but I wanted to know :
1) how will the model know what keywords or sentences it must keep for summarizing , and then how does the decoder for sentences ?
2 )can I use neural language model for framing sentences back ?
but I didn’t get how to solve the (1) problem
From what I understand, samples are the number of rows (either the entire dataset or a subset of it) we have in a data frame; features are the independent variables (x-variables). I am confused about time steps. Is my understanding correct? I have a time series dataset of 10 features, 600 observations (rows). How do I set the input shape? Are there different ways of doing it? Thank you!
Thanks for your contributions Jason, I have been visiting your blog numerous times by now and they always leave me with a better understanding of concepts.
Anyway, I was wondering how to deal with each label having features being observed at an erratic interval. I have not yet found a solution how to deal with this. Maybe I’m overseeing something.
Would I have to divide the timesteps in really small intervals and set observations to 0 if not observed at that timestep? Would I compute a regular interval and add an offset feature? Or something else?
Is reshaping similar for the text classification problem? How can one reshape the input_shape when there are 30000 samples with 300 features each? Additionally, what will be the meaning of timestep here when it is not actually the time series data?
Thanks a lot for your wonderful tutorial. There is one thing that i do not follow. if a have 7000 dataset (samples), that each one contains 3 time series with lenght 3000 timesteps, and now i want to do binary classification on each dataset(anomaly detection) (for each sample) using LSTM,
my question is, how do i proceed? how does my input look like? because (7000, 3000, 2) is too big for lstm .The lenght of my timeseries is huge( 3000). I have read this tutorial as well, but my problem is, that i want to use all information in my training.
Thanks again, but i have read that link you provided before. But my problem is, I know how the input for small time series in my case should look like(7000, num_time steps , 2). But in this case each of my time series has 3000 time steps (each of 7000 sample).
So, my question is how we can feed this input shape (7000, 3000,2) optimally into LSTM, because as you mentioned in one of your tutorial before, the optimum length of time series should be less that 400 time steps for LSTM. My case is Special since each of a data sets (each of 7000 sample) are independent from each other and my task is to classify them as anomaly or not anomaly, however the length of each time series is 3000 and it reduce the accuracy of the model.
I am new in ML and I have some confusion in the Dense layer and Dense output what is the difference between the two examples below, as shown below I put the number of features at was one to predict put example two why add dense like LSTM and output dense 32.
its very important for me can you help me
thank you.
1)
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(32, input_shape=(10, 2)))
model.add(Dense(1))
2)
model = Sequential()
model.add(Dense(32, input_shape=(16,)))
model.add(Dense(32))
Hi Jason,
I a dataset that has 3 features and each feature has been represented by a 200-dimension vector.
([200d],[200d],[200d]), label.
I wonder how to reshape the data for LSTM?
Thanks
actually each time step has a feature in vector form. I ‘ve got an error of datatype in Keras. It expects float.
the error is ”
could not convert string to float”
suppose I have a GRU network. I want each input in a vector format. Most
of the instances that I have seen are in integer form. What should i do
to give the gru an input in vector form?
Hello, Jason. Thanks for good explanation.
Could you please help to understand following questions:
1. LSTM with timestep = 1 – is it a simple MLP or it is still using hidden state / cell state? What’s state initial value in case of timestamp = 1?
2. Recommendation for LSTM autoencoder timestep selection?
Data example: index – week number, feature1 – number of visits per week, feature2 – number of holidays per week, feature3 – number of room visits.
Hi Jason,
Do you have a blog on how the shape of the input data changes at each gate of LSTM?
lets say your input shape is (1000,10,36) and it is passed to LSTM(64) then what will be the shape of output at each gate of LSTM(i.e after forget gate, input gate and output gate)
The exmaple given is wrongly re-shaped.
It shall have the shape of (2,10,1) and not (1,10,2) because there are 2 sequences with 10 time stamp observations with only 1 feature at a given time.
#Build the LSTM
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(100, input_shape=(450, 11)))
model.add(Dense(1))
model.add(Activation(‘softmax’))
model.compile(loss=’categorical_crossentropy’, optimizer=Adam(0.001), metrics[‘accuracy’])
model.summary()
model.fit(X_train,y_train, batch_size=88, epochs=40, validation_split=0.2)
I get the following error message:
ValueError: Error when checking target: expected activation_10 to have 2 dimensions, but got array with shape (140, 600, 1). I cant seem to fit the model.
#Build the LSTM
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(100, input_shape=(600, 7)))
model.add(Dense(1))
model.add(Activation(‘softmax’))
model.compile(loss=’categorical_crossentropy’, optimizer=Adam(0.001), metrics[‘accuracy’])
model.summary()
model.fit(X_train,y_train, batch_size=140, epochs=40, validation_split=0.2)
ValueError: Error when checking target: expected activation_10 to have 2 dimensions, but got array with shape (140, 600, 1). I cant seem to fit the model.
It looks like I was dealing with a Multivariate LSTM of Multiple Inputs. I have one question.
# split a multivariate sequence into samples
def split_sequences(sequences, n_steps):
X, y = list(), list()
for i in range(len(sequences)):
# find the end of this pattern
end_ix = i + n_steps
# check if we are beyond the dataset
if end_ix > len(sequences):
break
# gather input and output parts of the pattern
seq_x, seq_y = sequences[i:end_ix, :-1], sequences[end_ix-1, -1]
X.append(seq_x)
y.append(seq_y)
return array(X), array(y)
# define input sequence
in_seq1 = array([10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80, 90])
in_seq2 = array([15, 25, 35, 45, 55, 65, 75, 85, 95])
out_seq = array([in_seq1[i]+in_seq2[i] for i in range(len(in_seq1))])
# convert to [rows, columns] structure
in_seq1 = in_seq1.reshape((len(in_seq1), 1))
in_seq2 = in_seq2.reshape((len(in_seq2), 1))
out_seq = out_seq.reshape((len(out_seq), 1))
# horizontally stack columns
dataset = hstack((in_seq1, in_seq2, out_seq))
# choose a number of time steps
n_steps = 3
# convert into input/output
X, y = split_sequences(dataset, n_steps)
In the example that you posted. It creates a 3D shape(7,3,2) from the original sequences of 9 rows and 2 columns.
In practice, how will it work? My idea was to give a 2D tensor(100,3) of a fixed size and as an output get (100,) 100 outputs. I believe that lstm’s predict one output by one output. right?
That means that if I want to get the 100 outputs I will need to feed the neural network with these 2D tensor(100,3) –> reshape it into a 3D shape of lets say (90,10timestemps,3 features) and concatenate all the outputs into an array untill I get 90 outputs?
I have read your other blogs and they were very helpful for me as a beginner in machine learning. I haven’t done LSTMs before. this is my first time.
I am currently trying to train video sequence data to classify the emotions involved. However, by looking at the data I am a little confused about how to model my LSTM.
My data consists of a single feature (vector of length 8192) extracted from every 90 consecutive frames from each of 615 short video clips. the video clips are having the same sample rate.
the label for each sample (each video) is a 6 X 1 vector (6 different emotions)
I know that when I am modeling the LSTM I need not bother about 615 as it is the number of samples. but how would I deal with 90 frames?. is that the number of time steps to LSTM?
Can u please tell me how I should input the data to LSTM and input shape to LSTM?
Does
8192 is the shape of flattened feature output from InceptionV3 for each of the frames in the video.
Shape of Y_train = (543,6,1)
the problem now I am facing is that my model accuracy does not go beyond 30.
I tried adding a dense layer of different shapes before the softmax unit, also tried with different lstm unit shapes as well. changing the batch size or optimizer is also not improving accuracy.
Can you please look into my model and help me out with where I am making the mistake.
Hi Jason,
Thank you for your continued, top-class posts. I’ve a question in reshaping the dimension of the training data for LSTM. My data has 11 features and 544 observations. If I set timesteps = 1, my samples are 544/1 = 544 and the dimensions of data are correctly set to: dim(data) = c(544, 1, 11). However, when I set the timestep to, say, 7 and samples to 544/7, the dimensions of data aren’t set by dim(data) = c(544/7, 7, 11) and I get the error:
dims [product 5929] do not match the length of the object [5984].
Based on one of your FAQs, I assumed that the samples X timesteps = number of rows in the data. Can you please advise what am I doing wrong here?
Thank you for your reply. I did follow this link and got an idea that for non-intersecting blocks of observations, samples X timesteps = number of rows in the data. Since my data is daily time series and I want to treat each row as one training instance or sample, I kept the timesteps = 1 and hence, the samples = 544/1 = 544. However, if I wish to change the timesteps to any other value, I get the error as mentioned in my earlier post.
Can you please clarify how to reshape the data in R using the dim() function so that it matches the LSTM requirement? If I add the 3rd dimension, is it the timesteps? Besides, why is the number of timesteps = 1 a strange move? I’ll be obliged for your help.
For example, I’m using every past 7 days’ data to predict today’s value (price).
Each day, there is one record of 6 features (Let’s call them feature1 – feature5, and price).
Suppose I have 1000 days of data.
Now I take [i:i+7] as my X, [i+7+1][price] as my y. Therefore, the shape of X is 993*7*6, the shape of y is 993.
Does the shape of X match [samples][timesteps][features]?
Or should I create 42 features in each row, e.g. t-1, t-2, …, t-7? then timesteps is 1, features is 42?
Thanks for your reply.
What do you mean by reducing to 200-400? Do you mean 7 days’ data is too small? Perhaps I should use, for example, past 500 days’ data as my X?
Sorry, I meant perhaps change the framing of the problem to have a maximum of 200-400 time steps, which is reported to be a reasonable limit for LSTMs in practice.
Dear Jason.
My question is suppose I have a model lstm/dropout/LSTM/dropout/flatten/dense
then no. of hidden layers here will be 5 ie dropout/LSTM/dropout/flatten/dense
and if my data 2000 feature by 62 samples can I rehape it as 62,1,2000..
and what should be the no of Input lstm neurons/cells 2000 or not.
Regards Srirupa
Thank u Jason.
Now what should be the ans of this question
suppose I have a model lstm/dropout/LSTM/dropout/flatten/dense
then no. of hidden layers here will be 5 ie dropout/LSTM/dropout/flatten/dense
regards Srirupa
Jason..Thank u every time for you response.
Continuing the last query ..it means suppose I have lstm(128)/dropout(0.2)/lstm(64)/dropout(0.2)/flatten()/dense(1)..should there be 3 hidden layers excluding dropout and input lstm layer..
Please do reply..it is really helpful for me
Regards Srirupa
I have n samples, each sample has 49 timesteps (past observations) and 2 features each (x and y coordinates). I want the network to learn the next timestep (50th), so that it can predict next x and y coordinate.I implemented a LSTM network but it is not learning. I think the problem comes from the shape of the output. Do I have to reshape my target set so that it has shape (n_samples, 2) or do I have to modify the output dense layer and set the layer size to 2 ? I do not understand how to tell my network that the output is 2D….
I am currently working with a LSTM architecture with some video skeleton data. I have prepared my data in the same way as above (multiple arrays, 144 features and varying number of frames for different video sequences). However, I am not too sure how I can reshape my training data for the input tensor. The question is that usually when you are dealing with video sequences that have different number of frames for different video samples, what would be an appropriate way to reshape the training data (video samples)? I was thinking since the input time steps are going to be fixed, maybe one way is to sample the same number of video frames for each video sequence, at the cost of losing some information. I would like to ask you opinion on this if possible. Many Thanks.
My takeaway from the idea described in the code above is that maybe the only way is to use the predefined input time steps to sample frames for each video sequence and start from there.
hi, Jason,
i am codeing about lstm model with keras recently, but i have some questions about the data shape. i have data like this:
[list([[1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8], [9, 10, 11, 3, 6, 5, 5, 4, 4, 12]])
list([[13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 1, 19], [16, 14, 18, 1, 20, 14, 21, 22]])
list([[1, 2, 23, 6, 24, 25, 7, 26, 27], [28, 28, 29, 30, 31, 23, 1, 4, 6, 7, 25, 26], [32, 29, 33, 34, 17, 33, 1, 23, 6, 7, 35, 26]])]
the first row/list, it is diagnoses about one patient, it consits of two visit, the first visit contains 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8 diagnose,the second visit contains 9,…,12 diagnose. For different patient, there is different visit times, and for each visit, there is different length of diagnose code.
How should i build a lstm model with this data? Looking forward to your replying!
I am trying to train a lstm model with multiple time series of varying length. For purpose of training, I have segmented each clip with a window size of 25ms. For each such segment, I extract 5 features.
So, in summary #Samples = #Audio Clips, #Timesteps = #Segments (which varies for each file) and #Features = 5 (Fixed).
My Doubts:
1) Should I necessarily fix the #Timesteps by padding or dividing the longer files into smaller parts?
2) If it is not required, then in which data type should I arrange the 3D Input?
Hi, nice explanation, but I am struggling with a problem if we assume sample as 1, but my dependent variable has for example shape (50000,1) then how to reshape to match the sample dimension? I cannot change sample to 50000 as that would exceed the matrix integer values, please let me know what to do.
I’m struggling with a problem, if I have the training set as [Samples=1 ,Timestep=6, Feature=6] and I put the lstm input shape as (Samples=1 ,Timestep=6, Feature=1), are the remaining features ignored or repeated until the 6th feature?
I am doing a time series classification.
If I want to use the hourly data, which are 24 values per day, to classify the ID, does the input shape will be like (sample number, 24, 1)?
Or it should be (sample number, 1, 24)?
I read most of the comment but a little confused. If the number of neuron is not relvent to input timestamp, is it mean that the network will feed the data according to timestamps?
For example, if timestamp is 24, and feature is 2, each rnn neuron will be feed 24 times, and 2 feature will be feed in each time?
I have a question. What is the relation between data and its shape with the neural network. For instance if I have data with shape (45,1,700) How should the neural network be like for predicting output?
I am working on a text classification model, I use the Keras functional API, I want to concatenate the three flatten outputs of a CNN multi-channel for text (size (0.768) ) with an additional features vector that has 16 features for each word and next fed this vector to an LSTM network. I’m a bit confused about how to reshape this vector.
goal is to train a model that can predict patient’s mortality based on four physiological measurements for 48 hours after admitting to ICU.
Description and Data
Link to download data: https://www.dropbox.com/s/si0acy6z67wk0y9/Midterm2.zip?dl=0
In train folder, you are given four csv files (Heart.csv, Temperature.csv, Respiration.csv, Glucose.csv) containing four physiological measurements for the same 2000 patients admitted to ICU in a hospital. Rows represents patients and the columns represent the physiological measurements of the patient taken hourly. There are 48 columns indicating the first 48 hours after the patient is admitted to ICU. 50% of patients survives the ICU and the remaining 50% die at some point after the first 48 hours.
The class labels are stored in y_train.csv (1: survives, 0: death). y_train.csv has only one column that indicates the class labels. Assume that order of patients in y_train.csv and the measurement csv files are same.
First, you need to load these four files to a numpy tensor x_train of shape (2000,48,4) which in the form of (# of training samples, # of time steps, # of features). Here # of time steps is 48 and # of features = 4 (four physiological metrics). This can be done in different ways. One way to do is to first create an empty x_train tensor of shape (2000,48,4). Load each of the csv file and simply copy data to x_train along the final axis. For example x_train[:,:,0] can store the heart measurements, x_train[:,:,0] can store the Temperature measurements and so on. Also, load class labels to y_train tensor of shape (2000,)
In test folder, you are also given four csv files (Heart.csv, Temperature.csv, Respiration.csv, Glucose.csv) containing four physiological measurements for the same test 400 patients. You will need to load these four files to x_test tensor of shape (400,48,4). The class labels are stored in y_test.csv (1: survives, 0: death). Also, load class labels to y_test tensor of shape (400,). y_test.csv has only one column that indicates the class labels. Assume that order of patients in y_test.csv and the measurement csv files are same.
Model:
Create a keras CNN model that contains the following layers
• 1D CNN layer
• ReLU activation layer.
• 1D MaxPooling layer of window size = 4, stride = 1.
• Flatten layer.
• Output Dense Layer with one node and sigmoid activation.
• Use binary cross entropy as the loss function
• Use early stopping criteria, with patience = 3.
Hyperparameter optimization
In the model above, perform hyperparameter optimization for the following hyperparameters. The different options for each hyperparameter to be explored are shown. Only one method of hyperparameter optimization is necessary.
• Kernel length = 3, 5.
• Number of kernels = 6, 32, 64, 92.
• Batch size = 20, 30, 50.
• Optimizers = Adam, SGD, RMSprop.
• Learning rate = 1*lr, 0.1*lr, 10*lr, where lr is the default learning rate of the optimizer in Keras.
first of all all of your articles are very helpful, thanks!
I got the problem that eventhough reshape went fine I get an error that the test data does not fit to the train data considering the dimensions.
So I have a dataframe with [5000,140]. Trough split 80/20 I get train_data=(4000,140) and test_data=(1000,140). Trough reshaping, if I understood it correctly, this sould be train_data=(1,4000,140) and test_data=(1,1000,140) ?
Now even if the reshaping is correct, when running the autoencoder I get an error at validation_data, that time steps of train and test data is not equal but it mus be. What does that mean? How can I reshape the dimensions correctly so that this error does not occur?
Great post Jason. I have a question. My data set is 600 time-sequences of two features. So (600,2) dimensional array. I reshaped it as suggested by you to (1,600,2) or (3,200,2). This is my X_train. I’m not sure what my y_train should be?
As per the structure of LSTM, this must be a single value (for (1,600,2)) or 3 values (3,200,2). What exact values should there be in this array?
I am trying to develop a model to classify a given sequence of values. Would really appreciate any guidance.
If I understand it correctly when my test data is (1,600,2), the y_train should be (1,) with the class label as an element. How should I handle this when I split this into (3,200,2) as you suggested?
My class labels wouldn’t work here because they stand for an entire class of 600 time steps.
I hope I have explained the scenario properly and looking forward to your response.
greeting sir i am a computer science student and specialize in software engineering and i am currently working on my final year project. my project says that i’m supposed to predict the life cycle of a given polymer(until it ruptures) so in my dataset there is 3 colomns the force aplied to the polymer during a specific hours, it gives us the stress on the polymer so the outpute is one numirical value whice is the stress value (non_lineare regression) i tryed working with the CNN but i couldn’t so i’m trying to use the LSTM network but the structure of my data needs to split randomly as the train_test_split function do but every LSTM network I saw uses a manualy patern that allows the data to be splited sequencly so it’s easier to append the time sequence to the training and testing data so i’m wondering if the LSTM works fine for this regression probleme and a tutorial how to append the time sequence to the outpute variables of the train_test_split function (ndarrays) knowing that i tried to convert them to arrays and lists but unfortunately there is alyawes an error pops up i really need the answer, and sorry for my english it’s not my language thanks
The MSE ranges from 0 to 30 (0..30), the CR ranges from 0 to 5 (0..5) and the Age ranges from 30 to 45 (30..45).
As you can see, we have different rows regarding same device (for example in the table below we have three different readings regarding device#3). My goal s to use LSTM to predict the future reading for all the devices that we have in our dataset; in other word what is the MSE and CDR for device#3?
Can you please help me is this something applicable, is so, what data preparation I need to feed to LSTM.
Sir,
I have a dataset of 444 rows and 81 columns ( features). I need to input this to LSTM. How do i convert this data to 3D data to input to LSTM model.
Hi Jason,
I have a doubt. Is it possible that the dimension of input and output of a bidirectional RNN (GRU/LSTM)is equal?
Eg. If the input layer dimension is (128,16,128) followed by BiDirectional GRU with a hidden layer dimension of 32 and the output we get is also equal to Input i.e. (128,16,128) ??
Hi Jason,
Thanks for the swift response. I tried but when I use 32 as hidden units in Bi-GRU I am getting output dimension as (None, 64,32) for input dimension (None, 64,16).
import keras
from keras.models import Sequential
from keras.layers import LSTM, Dense, Dropout, LSTM
from keras.optimizers import Adam
import pandas as pd
#dataset import
dataset = pd.read_csv(‘C:\\Users\\Fatima\\Downloads\\train_subject1_raw01.csv’) #You need to change #directory accordingly
#print(dataset.head(10))
X = dataset.iloc[:,:32].values
y = dataset.iloc[:,32:33].values
#Normalizing the data
from sklearn.preprocessing import StandardScaler
sc = StandardScaler()
X = sc.fit_transform(X)
#print(X)
from sklearn.preprocessing import OneHotEncoder
ohe = OneHotEncoder()
y = ohe.fit_transform(y).toarray()
from sklearn.model_selection import train_test_split
X_train,X_test,y_train,y_test = train_test_split(X,y,test_size = 0.2)
#Import the libraries
import math
from math import sqrt
import numpy as np
from numpy import concatenate
import pandas as pd
from pandas import DataFrame
from pandas import concat
from pandas import read_csv
from sklearn.preprocessing import MinMaxScaler
#from sklearn.preprocessing import LabelEncoder
from sklearn.metrics import mean_squared_error
from keras.models import Sequential
from keras.layers import Dense, LSTM
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
from matplotlib import pyplot
#plt.style.use(‘fivethirtyeight’)
# ensure all data is float
values = values.astype(‘float32′)
# normalize features
scaler = MinMaxScaler(feature_range=(0, 1))
scaled = scaler.fit_transform(values)
# split the dataset into 75/25 for train and test
training_dataset_length = math.ceil(len(dataset) * .75)
print(training_dataset_length)
train = values[:training_dataset_length, :]
test = values[training_dataset_length:, :]
# split into input and outputs
train_X, train_y = train[:, :-1], train[:, -1]
test_X, test_y = test[:, :-1], test[:, -1]
Hi Jason,
Thank you for your great post. I have a dataset of 5000 patients. For each patient, a biosignal has been recorded for 60 seconds with a frequency of 80Hz, i.e. I have 5000 univariate samples with each sample containing 4800 data points. I want to classify my time series into two categories (mortality vs. non-mortality). If I want to use LSTMs or CNNs for classification, could you please let me know how I should structure X_train and what the input_shape looks like? As far as I’ve understood, the time step should be between 200-400 for LSTMs. Let’s say I pick 200. Is either of these two situations correct?
1) Do I have to split each signal into 200 segments? Since each segment would have 24 data points (4800/200 = 24), do I have to convert each segment to a single number (for example by averaging the 24 values)? Is it correct to say that:
X_train = (5000, 200)
input_shape = (5000, 200, 1)?
2) Do I have to divide each patient’s signal into 24 samples (with each sample containing 200 datapoints)? Is it correct to say that:
X_train = (24*5000, 200)
input_shape = (24*5000, 200, 1)?
I try to avoid being perspective as there is no single best way to frame a prediction problem. Instead, try a few different framings for your data and discover what works well or best.
I tried to apply the concepts on pretty simple example.
I got the close price of a stock for 5 years (i.e 1500 values) , and try to predict the close price of stock for the day after
I’d like to take into consideration 10 previous samples in order to predict the next day.
So the time series is one feature and the Y( the target) is the same time series shifted by one day
Then after have normalized both and split between training and test
X_scaled, Y_scaled X_scaled_train, Y_scaled_train
Now I have to reshape the X_scaled_train before passing it to the LSTM, but not the Y_scaled_train (correct?)
….
The input to every LSTM layer must be three-dimensional.
The three dimensions of this input are:
• Samples. One sequence is one sample. A batch is comprised of one or more samples.
• Time Steps. One time step is one point of observation in the sample.
• Features. One feature is one observation at a time step.
….
In this case 1500 samples should be reshaped to 150 (1500/10)
Hi Jason! Thank you for your work!! I have a question: In my work I have a dataframe in which each line has a patient record over the years and each column is a feature. The output is 0 or 1, depending on whether the patient has the disease or not.
Example for 2 years with 5 features: X is [[1 2 3 4 5], [1 3 5 6 4]] and the output [0 1]
My goal is through an LSTM to be able to predict whether a next patient will have the disease or not, but I don’t understand how I should reshape the data. For 10 years and 5 features, I have a y with 10 values (one for each year) and should I put the X in what shape?
You have a tutorial about Human Activity Recognition with LSTM. In that example, the input shape is (128,9). It means 128 time steps and 9 features. Also the batch size equals 64. As far as I understood, it indicates that in each process, 64 samples are fed to the network, and each sample contains 128 time steps and 9 features. Am I right?
In that tutorial, it is mentioned that there is a 50% overlap window because 128/64 = 2. I am confused about the meaning of overlap here. When in each process 64 samples are fed into the layer, how window overlapping occurs?
Overlap is a concept specific to time series. Imagine you have time 1, 2, 3, etc. And you have a window of size 10. Obviously the first window of data is 1 to 10, but what about second window of data? In case of 50% overlap, that is 6 to 15. In case of 0% overlap, you use 11 to 20.
Hi Jason
I changed the code to compatible with my data,( a csv file with 405-time step and 920 feature)
when I run the code I after epoc 1 the loss is nan and the output vector is completely nan
I have tested it for a small file (csv file with 405 timesteps and 4 features) it correctly works.
can you help me if it is possible?
The array is shaped in the form of:
number of samples = batch size = 1
number of time steps = number of rows = 10
number of features = number of columns = 1
Questions for clarification:
(1)number of samples = batch size = 1 – is that a one step ahead prediction:?
if
2(a) number of samples = batch size =2 is that 2 steps ahead prediction?
2(b) Can we predict one step ahead even though batch size = 2?
2(c) Setting a model,with batch_size >= 2 – input_shape for LSTM 3 parameters.
model.add(LSTM(32, input_shape=(2, 10, 1)))
The batch size here should be how much your LSTM should remember in the hidden layer. You always get one step ahead prediction but the batch size tells when you should reset the hidden state.
Thanks so much for all this content, it is the web I have seen on the internet.
I have a question regarding a problem I want to solve. I have a signal (voltage along time) with periodicity, and I want to detect with a neural network when this period decreases a certain percentage so I can activate an actuator (on-off actuator). I have read your book about LSTMs, and I think that I can use a Sequence Classification LSTM arquitecture. Does this makes sense?
Also I don’t know how to prepare the data for the x and y inputs of the fitting model. My guess is that x would be the voltage along time, and y would be the booelan values of this actuator (i.e. when the period decreases). Is this correct?.
Hello. I have a problem related to those things. I have sequential data and every input of one sample composed of 4 different time series. As an output, I have one time series for each sample that having same length with the inputs. When I rearranging the matrices, naturally input have 4x rows than the output. And keras gave the error “ValueError: Data cardinality is ambiguous:
x sizes: 504
y sizes: 126
Make sure all arrays contain the same number of samples.”
How can i solve this problem? Row number must be same but i have 4 input rows and one output row for every sample.
Goodmorning sir, thank you for your explanation.
My questione Is: how to treat with more than One sample with different timestep each? Should I reshape them? And then, what It I apply the model on Real Life? Does the length of timestep must match or It’s Just a training problem?
I’ve beeing using your examples and explanations on my learnings and job activities.
I have a question regarding the shape, that’s why I came back to the basics, but I still didn’t find my answer and would like to share my example.
I have a Multi-Channel Multi Step Input
( 1000 samples , 20 timesteps, 4 features).
While training this 3D Input with LSTM and CNN it works fine, but I was wondering if I could improve the speed and spare some resources of my modell, since 3 of these features doesn’t change inside the sample.
imagine that just the first feature is changing ( curve) (like a sinus curve with noise) during all 20 timesteps, but all other 3 features are relative constant ( Temperature, Pressure, Humidity).
curve = [0,18,36,54,72 …. 344]
feature_temp = [10,10,10,10,11…10]
feature_press = [990,991,991,991,….,991]
feature_humidity = [60,60,60,60…..60]
I was wondering:
Is there anyway to feed a modell with an mixed Input (1000,20,1) and (1000,1,3)? I would like to feed the curve and the mean of the features.
I was wondering if I could just add the mean of the features as last timesteps for each curve, but I’m affraid it’s not the real approach.
Thank you very much for your courses, books, blog entries and of course for a reply
Great explanation of the dimensions! Just wanted to say this explanation also works for LSTM models in Tensorflow as well.
Thanks Steven.
Hi Jason,
Thanks a lot for your explanations .
I have a confusion below:
Assuming that we have multiple parallel series as input for out model.The first step is to define these data as a matrix of M columns with N rows.To be 3D(samples, time steps, and features),is this means that,samples :1 sample ,time steps: row numbers of the matrix ,and features: column numbers of the matrix ? Must it be like this?Looking forward to your reply.Thank you
Sorry, I’m not sure I follow your question.
If you have parallel time series, then each series would need the same number of time steps and be represented as a separate feature (e.g. observation at a time).
Does that help?
Agree with Yuan on this issue
Hi Yuan,
I got your question. You have doubt that can we say the number of rows is the time steps and number of columns is features. Yes you can understand this way also.
That is , sample, time steps and features is equivalent to sample, number of rows, number of columns respectively.
Hello Sir,
I have used your multivariates code for testing lstm model.Its working fine but I did not understand why lstm one row is hidden from train as well as test dataset. If I test two rows in test then got one prediction as a output. And datetime output this one prediction result?
Please help me.
Thanks in advance.
Azad
Sorry, I don’t follow.
Perhaps you can elaborate on your question?
hi jason,your artical is very inspire.
Now i am working with loan risk control. i have client repayment time difference for each period. i am working on use time series modle on time difference before to predite the client will overdue.
suppose i have 10000 client and for each client i have 6 period repayment time difference. as the artical you write my input data orginal is (10000*6).before i send it to LSTM model i should reshape it to 10000*6*1 3D dataset? is that the right way to do it? if you have any other experience of this problem you can tell me as well.
Sounds like it would be [10000, 6, 1]
HI, I think wanghy wants to make a loan risk forecast.
The customer should pay 6 repayments for each loan.
So if you use [10000,6,1] to train the model,
how do you feed data when making prediction after 3 replayments have done
Perhaps you can make 1 step forecasts based on zero or more input time steps and use zero padding to fill out the inputs?
e.g.
thanks jason
I am still confused about the timesteps.
Suppose the customer pays 240 repayments for each loan (20 years) and the loan risk is related to the latest year’s repayments.
So, the train data should be [rows, 12, 1] instead of [rows, 240, 1], right?
Sometimes, the values of timesteps and features are very large, such as 1024, 512.
How to choose the value of the timesteps when the memory is not enough?
This explains it well:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Trial and error is a good approach, test different framings of the problem and see what works best.
thanks very much
sir i am working on prediction problem , i have an experimental data in 1D colunm for 8000 elements and also 3D data distributed alonh spatial coordinates like [x y z value]. now i have confusion how i use my 1D data and then 3D data for prediction.
Perhaps this will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hi Jason,
thanks a lot for all the explanations you gave!
I tried to understand the effect of the reshape parameters and the effect in the spyder/variable explorer. But I do not understand the result shown in the data window.
I used the code from a different tutorial:
data = array([
[0.1, 1.0],
[0.2, 0.9],
[0.3, 0.8],
[0.4, 0.7],
[0.5, 0.6],
[0.6, 0.5],
[0.7, 0.4],
[0.8, 0.3],
[0.9, 0.2],
[1.0, 0.1]])
data_re = data.reshape(1, 10, 2)
When checking the result in the variable explorer of spyder I see 3 dimensions of the array but can not connect it to the paramters sample, timestep, feature.
On axis 0 of data_re I see the complete dataset
On axis 1 of the data_re I get 0.1 and 1.0 in column 1
On axis 2 of the data_re I see the column 1 of axis 0 transposed to row 1
Would you give me a hint how to interpret it?
Regards,
Oliver.
There are no named parameters, I am referring to the dimensions by those names because that is how the LSTM model uses the data.
Sorry for the confusion.
Hi Jason,
Thanks so much for the article (and the whole series in fact!). The documentation in Keras is not very clear on many things on its own.
I have been trying to implement a model that receives multiple samples of multivariate timeseries as input. The twist is that the length of the series, i.e. the “time steps” dimension is different for different samples. I have tried to train a model on each sample individually and then merge, (but then each LSTM is going to be extremely prone to overfitting). Another idea was to scale the samples to have the same time steps but this comes with a scaling factor of time steps for each sample which is not ideal either.
Is there a way to provide the LSTM with samples of dynamic time steps? maybe using a lower-level API?
Regards,
Saga
A way I use often is to pad all sequences to the same length and use a masking layer on the front end to ignore masked time steps.
HI Jason,
Thank you for this amazing article.
I have the same problem here. which is the samples have many different lengths.
I did not get the idea you said.
“A way I use often is to pad all sequences to the same length and use a masking layer on the front end to ignore masked time steps.”
can you please provide more details about that?
or maybe provide articles explain how to solve this problem.
Thank you in advance.
These examples will show you how to truncate and pad sequence data:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/data-preparation-variable-length-input-sequences-sequence-prediction/
Hi Jason,
Thanks very much for your tutorials on LSTM. I am trying to predict one time series from 10 different parallel time series. All of them are different 1D series. So, the shape of my X_train is (50000,10) and Y_train is (50000,1). I couldn’t figure out how to reshape my dataset and the input shape of LSTM if I want to use let’s say 100 time steps or look back as 100.
Thanks.
This post will help you formulates your series as a supervised learning problem:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/convert-time-series-supervised-learning-problem-python/
Respected Sir
I want to use LSTM RNN GRU to check changes in facial expression of the person who is watching a movie. Want to check his mental state whether he is a boar or interested to continue this movie or at what time he is a boar. Can you please help me how can I start to work on same.
That sounds like a great problem. I would recommend starting by collecting a ton of training data.
Then think of using a CNN on the front end of your LSTM.
Hi,
I have around 12,000 tweets for sentiment classification totally. Do you think 16GB CPU RAM will be enough?
Sure.
Hi Jason
Thanks for the simple explanation.
However, I have a doubt. What if you don’t know the no of time steps? How do you proceed then?
Is that why we use the embedding layer?
I intend to use it for sentiment analysis of imDb movie review dataset.
You can force all input sequences to be the same length by padding/truncating.
You could also use a model that does not specify the input length, for example:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/develop-encoder-decoder-model-sequence-sequence-prediction-keras/
Hi Jason,
I finally understood the input shape requirements.
Just a quick question: batch_size would be a certain number of samples inside a group e.g if we have 100 samples we can divide it into batches of 10. Batching helps with a faster training time right?
Correct, and weight updates occur and state is reset at the end of each batch.
Hi Jason,
About sample (the first argument in reshape): if I have two sequences with different number of values (let’s suppose one with 10 values and another with 8) and want them to be considered as two distinct samples (not 2 features), a zero-padding is necessary?
series 1: 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, 1.0
series 2: 1.0, 0.9, 0.8, 0.7, 0.6, 0.5, 0.4, 0.3, 0.0, 0.0
If I do:
data = data.reshape(2, 10, 1)
It is going to understand them as 2 different samples?
Yes, padding to 10 time steps.
Yes, your reshape looks good.
Explore pre and post padding to see if it makes a difference for your model.
With this input, the model is going to understand two different series?
Why to don’t use (1, 10,2) shape?
You could treat them as two features as you suggestion, I thought they were separate samples.
Hi Jason,
Thanks a lot for the tutorial!
I am trying to understand the input shape for LSTM data (No. of timesteps & no. of features). Could I ask what each will be in the context of the iris dataset, please?
Am I correct to say that in the iris dataset, the timesteps can be 2, 3, 5, 6 – as long as it neatly divides the dataset into equal number of rows (iris has 150 rows).
And the number of features will be the number of columns (apart from the target column/class)?
Thanks ever so much!
The iris dataset is not a sequence classification problem. It does not have time steps, only samples and features.
Hello!
First of all, thank you very much for your posts, I have learned a lot.
My question is because I’m not sure how to focus the next type of problems: multiples sequences of multiple features.
For example, predict the amount that a user could spend given the previous purchases (here I can consider different features such as the previous amounts, products, day of week, etc.). If I have a dataset with data of 1000 users and I want to predict the amount for each user, how should be addressed?
Can I use a lstm for all users or each user will have a model/lstm?
I understand that a lstm for all users could see things more interesting.. But I don’t know how to organize the input of different users.. because the example of two sequences (1,10,2) I don’t know how to apply.. I want to include more features for each sequence..
I’m very lost..
Thank you in advance
Perhaps start off by modeling individual users?
Thanks!
By modelling individual users do you mean a lstm per user?
I have users with 200 purchases but others only with only 10.. would be enough?
I will try!
Thanks!
Or a user per sample.
I’ have the same issue. It’s driving me crazy!
datetime user_id feture_1 feature_2 feature_3 …
2018-01-01 0 1 2 3 …
2018-01-20 0 3 49 15 …
2018-01-01 1 1 5 8 …
20118-02-25 1 3 5 15 …
targets
user_id target
0 0
1 1
I think I’ve two ways: one with DL Model (LSTM maybe) but I’m not sure how to organize trainig set. The other way could be by grouping features by userid and apply the cuount of the category feature (previos on_hot_encode) and apply Descition Trees model
How did you adress it??
You may have to transform the data prior to modeling.
E.g. sequence of prior user actions on day, week or month intervals and a user target output. Perhaps with zero padding on the input sequence.
Hi Jason,
Thanks for your tutorial and for your book!
I am not sure how to design the input shape of the following table or dataframe:
date, product, store, hasPromotion, attrib1, attrib2, quantity (t)
The first three columns are the key. We have 50000 products in 20 stores and I would like to predict the quantity (per product per store) at least 14 days ahead with LSTM.
What is the good start for the 3D input?
I am wondering if creating new features from date (as there are repetition), like day of week, day of month, month of year, etc. + the existing features + quantity (t), quantity (t+1) would do…
Thank you for your help in advance!
Br,
Drop date and you have 6 features, does that help?
OK, thanks. If there are seasonality and trend in sales, should I remove them before train the LSTM, too?
Yes, I would recommend that.
Howdy!
Thank you so much for the great amount of tutorials on LSTMs
Im trying to build an LSTM in keras using your examples and keep running into shape issues.
I have time series data set with prices for different things, and am trying to predict the price of item4 for time t+1
Item4 is a lagged value so that you can use previous set of prices to predict the next.
The data set has 400 sequential observations.
variables: datetime price1 price2 price3 item4_price
since the data variable has uniform interval of observations and none are missing, i am dropping the datetime variable.
So now i have 4 variables and 400 observations.
trainX = train[:, 0:-1] #use first 3 variables
trainY = train[:,-1] #use the last variable
so now the trainX data set has price1 price2 and price3 variables (its my undestanding that this means there are 3 “feautres” in keras)
trainY is the predictor data set and only cointains item4_price
trainX = numpy.reshape(trainX, (1, 400, 3)) #reshape, this means there is 1 sample, 400 timestamps, and 3 features
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(5, input_shape=(1, 400, 3), return_sequences=True))
model.add(Dense(1))
model.compile(loss=’mean_squared_error’, optimizer=’adam’)
model.fit(trainX, trainY, epochs=100, batch_size=1, verbose=2)
Keep getting various shape errors all the time, no matter what i do. I tried switching it around, and even ommiting the first dimension.
I was wondering if you could point me in the right dirrection of what it is that i keep missing in my understnading of keras/lstm shapes.
I also dont know if the trainY set needs shaping? I tried to shape it too but python was also not happy with that.
Let me know what you think!
Thanks,
Vic
Perhaps start with one series and really nail down what is required.
Did you try this tutorial:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/prepare-univariate-time-series-data-long-short-term-memory-networks/
Hi Dr. Brownlee,
I have previously read that tutorial and feel as though i understand it fine.
But when applying what I learned to the problem in a way as described previously, find that Im running into some trouble.
So i was hoping I was just overlooking something, but at this point im not really sure what. Is what Im doing seem reasonable?
Thanks!
Perhaps, but I don’t know your problem as well as you and there is no set way to solve any ml problem.
I would encourage you to brainstorm and try a suite of approaches to see what works best.
Hi Jason,
I have gone through this tutorial but i have a input size of 1762 X 4 and output size 1762X 1.
I did as follows but the shape of y train is giving as (1394, 4) , which should be 1394,1
Can you help me on this?
Sorry, I cannot debug your code for you. I simply do not have the capacity, I’m sure you can understand.
Perhaps post your error to stackoverflow or cross validated?
I got an exception “ValueError: Input arrays should have the same number of samples as target arrays. Found 1 input samples and 21 target samples”.
=>print X_train
[[ 0.15699646 -1.59383227]
[-0.31399291 -0.03680409]
[ 0.15699646 -1.59383227]
[-0.31399291 0.78456757]
[ 0.15699646 -1.59383227]
[ 4.39590078 -1.59383227]
[-0.31399291 1.38764971]
[-0.31399291 -0.03680409]
[-0.31399291 -0.32252408]
[-0.31399291 0.6081381 ]
[-0.31399291 -0.32252408]
[-0.31399291 1.38764971]
[-0.31399291 0.78456757]
[-0.31399291 -0.03680409]
[-0.31399291 0.78456757]
[ 0.15699646 1.24889926]
[-0.31399291 -0.32252408]
[-0.31399291 1.24889926]
[-0.31399291 -0.69488163]
[-0.31399291 -0.69488163]
[-0.31399291 0.6081381 ]]
=>print y_train
0 1
1 1
2 1
3 1
4 1
5 1
6 1
7 0
8 0
9 0
10 0
11 0
12 0
13 0
14 1
15 1
16 1
17 1
18 0
19 0
20 0
Name: out, dtype: int64
=>print(y_train.shape)
(21,)
=>print X_train.shape
(21, 2)
=>print X_test.shape
(8, 2)
I have reshaped the inputs to 3dimensional input. I have followed you steps.
=>X_train = X_train.reshape(1,21, 2)
print(X_train.shape)
(1, 21, 2)
=>
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(32, input_shape=(21, 2)))
model.add(Dense(1))
model.compile(optimizer=’rmsprop’,loss=’categorical_crossentropy’,metrics=[‘categorical_accuracy’])
history = model.fit(X_train,y_train,batch_size =13, epochs = 14)
—————————————————————————
ValueError Traceback (most recent call last)
in ()
—-> 1 history = model.fit(X_train,y_train,batch_size =13, epochs = 14)
/home/siji/anaconda2/lib/python2.7/site-packages/keras/models.pyc in fit(self, x, y, batch_size, epochs, verbose, callbacks, validation_split, validation_data, shuffle, class_weight, sample_weight, initial_epoch, **kwargs)
891 class_weight=class_weight,
892 sample_weight=sample_weight,
–> 893 initial_epoch=initial_epoch)
894
895 def evaluate(self, x, y, batch_size=32, verbose=1,
/home/siji/anaconda2/lib/python2.7/site-packages/keras/engine/training.pyc in fit(self, x, y, batch_size, epochs, verbose, callbacks, validation_split, validation_data, shuffle, class_weight, sample_weight, initial_epoch, steps_per_epoch, validation_steps, **kwargs)
1553 class_weight=class_weight,
1554 check_batch_axis=False,
-> 1555 batch_size=batch_size)
1556 # Prepare validation data.
1557 do_validation = False
/home/siji/anaconda2/lib/python2.7/site-packages/keras/engine/training.pyc in _standardize_user_data(self, x, y, sample_weight, class_weight, check_batch_axis, batch_size)
1419 for (ref, sw, cw, mode)
1420 in zip(y, sample_weights, class_weights, self._feed_sample_weight_modes)]
-> 1421 _check_array_lengths(x, y, sample_weights)
1422 _check_loss_and_target_compatibility(y,
1423 self._feed_loss_fns,
/home/siji/anaconda2/lib/python2.7/site-packages/keras/engine/training.pyc in _check_array_lengths(inputs, targets, weights)
249 ‘the same number of samples as target arrays. ‘
250 ‘Found ‘ + str(list(set_x)[0]) + ‘ input samples ‘
–> 251 ‘and ‘ + str(list(set_y)[0]) + ‘ target samples.’)
252 if len(set_w) > 1:
253 raise ValueError(‘All sample_weight arrays should have ‘
ValueError: Input arrays should have the same number of samples as target arrays. Found 1 input samples and 21 target samples.
Please solve my problem. I am new in this area. What is the mistake
Perhaps cut the example back to a few lines to help expose the fault?
Hi Jason,
I’m trying to understand the input_shape but I think I’m totally confused about the time step variable. I have a multivariate time series with 18,000 samples and 720 features. I created a 10 lagged observation dataset to forecast the next 5 time steps so my dataset goes from t-10 to t+5, being the feature dataset from t-10 to t and the label dataset from t+1 to t+5.
Assuming that I take 15,000 samples for training, what will be the values of the reshape function? I think it should be [15000, 1, 7200 (720 features * 10)]. Regarding the time step, is the value “1” correct or it should be the number of lagged observations, that is, 10?
Thank you in advance.
Generally, I would recommend about 200-400 time steps.
Here’s some more advice on how to handle a very long time series:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/handle-long-sequences-long-short-term-memory-recurrent-neural-networks/
And here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/prepare-univariate-time-series-data-long-short-term-memory-networks/
Hi Jason!
Thank you so much for all the tutorials on LSTMs, I’ve learned a lot.
I’m trying to implement the LSTM Architecture from the paper “Dropout improves Recurrent Neural Networks for Handwriting Recognition” for resolving the handwritten recognition problem.
Basically I have to train the network giving in input variable-sized images (different W and H but always 3 channels) and to predict what is the word written in the image. What I can’t understand is how to deal with variable sized images? Can I consider images as some sequences (for ex. a 50×30 image considered as 50 sequences with 30 features?). The authors say I give in input a block of image of size 2×2 scaning in 4 different directions (multidirectional multidimensional LSTM).
What do I have to specify here : input_size(Samples,Time Steps,Features) ? The Samples refers to the number of all images I have in training set or the number of miniblocks 2×2 ? What about time steps and features? I don’t get it and its very confusing. Can you please help with any idea? I am new in this area and Im stacked in this problem.
Thanks a lot 🙂
I would recommend padding the inputs to a fixed size.
Hi Jason!
Thanks so much for your tutorials on LSTM!
I’m trying to predict trajectory with LSTM and ARIMA now. After reading this tutorial, I’ve got some questions.
(1) Do we must transfer time series to lag observations if we want to do forecast work with LSTM?
(2) After transfering time series to supervised learning problems, the forecast is only related to “order” or “lag” rather than “time”(like ARIMA do)? Why the input is not time/date? And the time interval of data must be even?
Thanks a lot in advance!
No, LSTMs can work with the time steps directly.
The order of the observations is sufficient for the model, if the time steps are consistently spaced it does not need the absolute date/time information.
Hello Jason! Congratulations on the LSTM input tutorial!
Could you please answer three questions?
I’m working with 500 samples that have varying sizes. My doubts are related to the organization of these 500 samples within this 3-dimensional input, mainly in relation to the Samples dimension.
The dimension “Features” has already defined that it will have size 26, the dimension “Time Steps” will have to have size 100 but the dimension “Samples” is that I still do not know what its value will be.
Doubt 1: In these cases of samples with different sizes to know the dimension “Samples” I have to be based on the larger sample and for the other samples I fill in the value 0 (zero) in the additional spaces?
Doubt 2: Can I have more than one line in the “Samples” dimension representing the same sample?
Doubt 3: How do samples have varying sizes, there are possibilities to work with 4 dimensions, for example: “Samples” x “Part of Samples” x “Time Steps” x “Features”?
Thank you for your attention!
One sample is one sequence.
Each sample must have the same length, you can use zero-padding to achieve this and use Masking to ignore the padded obs.
This tutorial will make it clearer I think:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/prepare-univariate-time-series-data-long-short-term-memory-networks/
Hi Jason,
Thank you for such a good tutorial! This really helps!
I am not sure if I understand the model correctly:
The sequence of samples does matter in lstm because the state of current one is affected by last one in the sequence.
If this is the case, can you let me know how I should deal with the following scenarios?
I have non-equally spaced trajectory data. The interval varies from seconds to days. Solutions I come up with are interpolation or adding time feature. What do you think is a good way to prepare the data?
Assuming last problem is solved, how can I organize the input if my data contains trajectories of different people? For example, trajectory of one person is (100, 5, 2) and trajectory of another one is (200, 5, 2). How to train both sequence in one model?
Thank you very much!
Thanks.
Perhaps you can interpolate the data?
Perhaps you can use zero padding with a masking input layer to ignore the zeros?
I have more on preparing data for LSTMs here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/how-do-i-prepare-my-data-for-an-lstm
If each trajectory is a sample, and samples are independent, then perhaps use a batch size of 1 or reset at the end of each sample. Compare the skill of this model to one that does not reset state so often.
Hello Jason, you are making a good job Dr.! I am a bit confused about my data shape for the network: I have 300 different samples, where the next one always is measured lets say in 1 min steps, so I have in total 300 timesteps, and each file is containing 1 column, 2.000 rows. When we say I want to reduce the ‘features’, rows I am thinking that my inputshape must be therefore (1,300,2000) and than I can reduce to something e.g.200. with the lstm decoder ?
How can 1 sample have 300 time steps, 1 column and 2k rows? I do not understand sorry.
Sorrry for the obscurity, 1 sample has 2000 rows all in one column so only one type of value temperature is measured. in total I have 300 samples and time distance between their recording is 1 min
I still don’t follow.
Are the 2000 rows related in time for one feature? Or are the 2000 rows separate features at one time?
I think if I understood you right, the 2000 rows are related to one measurement (so I measure in 1 second 2000 times the temperature). But when you regard it with an lstm autoencoder I try to reduce the “features” to learn from them and make than the prediction. I do not know the shape for the lstm encoder decoder either it should be (1, 300,2000) or (2000,300,1) but for the last one I got strange results, the first one is closer to the real data. Which one is right ?
The input to the encoder will be [300, ?, 2000] where ? represents the number of time steps you wish to model.
The encoder decoder is not appropriate for all sequence prediction problems, it is suited to sequence output that differs in length to the input. If you are doing straight sequence classification/regression it might not be appropriate.
HI Jason, the example is really good. Besides this I have a question for my data. I have temperature values measured for a sampling rate of 1 second with a sampling frequency of 10.000. So I measure in 1 second 10.000 different values but same unit(lets say force). This I repeat with certain time intervals. Do I have than 10.000 different features or only one feature as input dimension ?
Sounds like 10K features at each time step.
this means that one time step can have 10k features?
An NLP problem may have 100K features or more.
great tutorial jason .. but i have a problem in the reshaping my RNN model,,
this my code
import numpy as np
from keras.datasets import imdb
from keras.models import Sequential
from keras.layers import Dense
from keras.layers import LSTM
from keras.layers import Bidirectional
from keras.preprocessing import sequence
# fix random seed for reproducibility
np.random.seed(7)
train = np.loadtxt(“featwithsignalsTRAIN.txt”, delimiter=”,”)
test = np.loadtxt(“featwithsignalsTEST.txt”, delimiter=”,”)
x_train = train[:,[2,3,4,5,6,7]]
x_test = test[:,[2,3,4,5,6,7]]
y_train = train[:,8]
y_test = test[:,8]
# create the model
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(20, input_shape=(10,6)))
model.add(Dense(1415684, activation = ‘sigmoid’))
model.compile(loss=’binary_crossentropy’, optimizer=’adam’, metrics=[‘accuracy’])
model.fit(x_train, y_train, epochs = 2)
What problem?
a problem of reshaping the dataset..
this is a sample of my dataset
a sample of my dataset (patient number, time in mill/sec., normalization of X Y and Z, kurtosis, skewness, pitch, roll and yaw, label) respectively.
1,15,-0.248010047716,0.00378335508419,-0.0152548459993,-86.3738760481,0.872322164158,-3.51314800063,0
1,31,-0.248010047716,0.00378335508419,-0.0152548459993,-86.3738760481,0.872322164158,-3.51314800063,0
1,46,-0.267422664673,0.0051143782875,-0.0191247001961,-85.7662354031,1.0928406847,-4.08015176908,0
1,62,-0.267422664673,0.0051143782875,-0.0191247001961,-85.7662354031,1.0928406847,-4.08015176908,0
Yes, what is the problem that you are having exactly?
i didn’t even know how to reshape my dataset to fit the RNN model.
can you please help me?
Here is a ton more help on the topic:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/how-do-i-prepare-my-data-for-an-lstm
i didn’t kow how td do it !
Take it slow, one step at a time.
this is what i have accomplished
train = np.loadtxt(“featwithsignalsTRAIN.txt”, delimiter=”,”)
test = np.loadtxt(“featwithsignalsTEST.txt”, delimiter=”,”)
x_train = train[:,[2,3,4,5,6,7]]
x_test = test[:,[2,3,4,5,6,7]]
y_train = train[:,8]
y_test = test[:,8]
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(64,activation=’relu’,batch_input_shape=(100, 10, 1),
stateful=True,
return_sequences=False))
model.add(Dense(1, activation=’linear’))
model.compile(loss=’mean_squared_error’, optimizer=’adam’)
is that true ??
Nice work.
What do you mean by true?
Our job is to find a model that gives “good enough” results when making predictions. This requires careful experimentation.
thank you. i have tried the following code
np.random.seed(7)
train = np.loadtxt(“featwithsignalsTRAIN.txt”, delimiter=”,”)
test = np.loadtxt(“featwithsignalsTEST.txt”, delimiter=”,”)
x_train = train[:,[2,3,4,5,6,7]]
x_test = test[:,[2,3,4,5,6,7]]
y_train = train[:,8]
y_test = test[:,8]
x_train = x_train.reshape((-1,1,6))
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(64,activation=’relu’,input_shape=(1, 6)))
model.add(Dense(1, activation=’softmax’))
model.compile(loss=’binary_crossentropy’,
optimizer=’adam’,
metrics=[‘accuracy’])
model.fit(x_train, y_train, batch_size = 128, epochs = 10, verbose = 2)
but it gets a very low accuracy with very high loss
Epoch 1/20 – 63s – loss: 15.0343 – acc: 0.0570
Epoch 2/20 – 60s – loss: 15.0343 – acc: 0.0570
Epoch 3/20 – 60s – loss: 15.0343 – acc: 0.0570
Epoch 4/20 – 60s – loss: 15.0343 – acc: 0.0570
Perhaps try other configurations, here are some ideas:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/improve-deep-learning-performance/
What does 32 in model.add(LSTM(32)) mean?
It means 32 LSTM units in the layer.
Would have been nice if you have added this info in your article.
Thanks for the suggestion, you can get started with the basics of LSTMs here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/start-here/#lstm
whether the layer can be determined arbitrarily? Or is there a stipulation?
Usually arbitrarily first, and then experiment to confirm it fits for the problem (i.e., test with your dataset)
Hi, Jason,
Thank you for the great tutorial. It helps me to predict time series data sequences with the lstm model.
However, I have a question about how to determine the length of look_back time steps.
For example, there is a time series sequence X1, X2, X3, …, Xn. When I apply ARIMA for prediction Xn+1, I can use ACF and PCF to determine the parameter pi and qi. The number of pi indicates the look_back time steps. Then, the ARIMA equation can be used to predict Xn+1.
But for lstm, I do not know how to determine the look_back time steps, in other words, the reshape size for a time series sequence. Is there any way to get an appropriate look_back time steps in reshaping the time series sequence data for lstm? Could you pls give me some suggestions about it?
Thanks a lot.
Suzi
Looking at ACF/PACF plots might be a good start to get an idea of the number of lag obs that are significant.
Thanks for your quick reply.
I am still confused about your suggestion. Do you mean that I need plot the ACF/PACF to find the number of time lag for applying lstm?
I do not think the the ACF/PACF can be used for determining the look_back time steps for lstm. These two criteria explain the linear correlation of time series.
For those nonlinear correlation time series sequences, the ACF/PACF is not truncating or tailing and ARIMA cannot be used to model them.
Then I use lstm to model the nonlinear correlation time series sequences and lstm is good at it. Unfortunately, the ACF/PACF is not able to find the time lag in applying lstm.
Before applying lstm for a time series prediction, I must decide the reshape size. However, I cannot find any information on the internet about how to determine it. Is there any book or tutorial can help me to solve this problem?
Thank you very much.
Yes, it is a useful guide / starting point.
I have a ton of advice on preparing data for LSTMs here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/how-do-i-prepare-my-data-for-an-lstm
Hi Jason,
Thanks for the article and clarifying the dimensions which some of us have trouble with them.
However, my question goes to something I didn’t find anybody asked in the Q&A:
Why do you put 32 units in the input LSTM layer?
I mean, if you have 2 features in each of the 10 time steps and one sample example, why would we want to have more than 10 neurons in the first input layer?
As I understand LSTMs, each neuron gets feed with the features of one specific time step (in the cell images of colah’s blog it is stated as Xt, as you will surely know).
If you feed the first one with “t” and continue like “t+1,t+2,t+3…t+10”, what time step will we use in the case of t+17 for example which would be the 17th neuron?
In fully connected ANN the first input layer has the same number of neurons that of features. Is there anything I’m missing or is there any rule to select the number of neurons if we choose that our input layer is a LSTMs one?
Thanks for the attention and for correcting any error that I may be not understanding.
The number of units in the hidden layer is unrelated to the number of input or output time steps.
We configure neural nets by trial and error, more here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/how-many-layers-and-nodes-do-i-need-in-my-neural-network
Hi again Jason,
Thanks for the quick reply.
Let me please introduce some numbers:
Input_shape = (300, 10, 2)
Batch_size = 1
Num_units in input/first LSTM layer = 32
So, as you say, if the units in the input LSTM layer (I am supposing that it is the first layer we use) are not related to the time steps, each time we feed a batch of data into that layer through “Xt” we will feed one row (one sample) of those 300 with 10 columns and we will do it two times: one for the first feature and another for the second feature, and the important point, this feeding will be to every unit of those 32 that compose the LSTM layer. Am I getting the point?
I get confused because in normal feedforward ANN, the first layer (the input layer) has as many nodes as features we have, so that we can feed each feature in one node.
If you could clarify this for me, you would be doing me a big favour because there is not much insight about this details elsewhere.
Thanks in advance,
If your batch size is 1, then each batch will contain one sample (sequence).
Yes, the sequence will be exposed to each unit in the first hidden layer.
Hi Jason,
Okey, perfect. Now I get almost all the points.
Thank you for your kindness,
Hey Jason,
i think i have the same question as Eriz had but i’m not sure whether i understood his explanation right, so i would be great if you could tell me if i got it right.
So the question is: How is the data fed into the first layer of a lstm/rnn ? (i hope there aren’t any differences)
Let’s take Eriz example: 32 Units in the first layer and an input shape of (300,10,2)
I understood Eriz like this:
For one example e (from the 300 examples) all 32 units in the first layer get the time series with length 10 of example e. And this seperately for each feature one after the other (in this case two times) before the network processes the next example.
Is this correct?
Also if we look at this typical illustration of a rnn:
http://www.wildml.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/rnn.jpg
Am i right that in this case the variable t in the image would be in the range of 1 <= x <= 10 ? (because of the length of the time series)
Thank you very much in advance, because i couldn't find any detailed description on how this works.
Each of the 32 units in the hidden layer are separate and do not interact.
For a given unit, it receives one time step of data at a time with 2 features. This continues until all 10 time steps have been shown, the final activation is then passed on to the next layer.
Does that help?
Somewhat. I now understand what happens for a single unit.
You said that all units are independent. Does that mean each of the units recieves the same data (the complete time series of an example) in the way you described in your second sentence?
Again, thank you for your effort.
Yes. Units in a layer do not interact, and each receives the entire input.
Hi Jason, thank you for the articles and books… I just have some open questions about shape. Since I have a 2D multivariate data ex: (samples = 1024, features = 6) , and make a supervised learning dataset with ten (10) lags, the shape will be (samples = 1024, features = 60).
The question is: The shape for LSTM is (samples, timesteps, features) so it will be data.reshape(1024, 10, 60) ? I dont, understand why some tutorials use something lile (1, 10, 1) and how to reshape/split train/test on the new shape. The steps are:
1 – convert to supervised problem.
2 – reshape the entire 2D dataset or split here and reshape after?
3 – how about shape of Y to make predictions?
I just need a step with these key points… Thanks for the excelent posts.
From your description, there is no need to worry about the lag, the time steps take care of that.
The shape would be (1024, 10, 6)
Hi again Jason, thanks for the reply. On your example for one and multiple features, you say:
– consider a matrix of 2 columns with 10 rows, This data can be framed as 1 sample with 10 timesteps and 2 features.
So, this “1 sample” is drive me crazy. When I have a 2D data like lines vs columns (sample, features), I thought the number of samples will be the number of lines of a matrix 2D data; So it always be (sample, features) –> (sample, timesteps, features). On your example, the rows turned into timesteps and I can’t realize this sample = 1 in this post. Why one sample? Why rows become timesteps here and become samples on other examples?
Another question is: After rechape input data, how to reshape X_train, y_train and new data for predictions.
It is challenging in the beginning.
Think about it like this: you are taking a 2D dataset and projecting it into a 3D space.
Hello,
Why do we need to reshape data on 3 dimensions for the LSTM
Thank you
Because LSTMs expect data as input in 3 dimensions.
Hi Thank you so much for this article, it helped me understand Keras and Overall Input thing.
I am really confused how can I prepare the output data. Overall the output
at one point we use
model.fit(X_train, y_train, validation_data=(X_test, y_test), epochs=3, batch_size=64)
I have (25000, 15) input shape, How can I prepare the overall output
Why, what problem are you having exactly?
Thanks for sharing. I am confused about the padding and “sliding window” method. Suppose the dataset contains two sequences s1,s2 and time_step is set to 3, then s1=(1,2,3,4,5) should have 2 subsequences: [(1,2,3), (2,3,4)], s2=(6,7,8,9,10,11,12) should have 4 subsequences: [(6,7,8), (7,8,9), (8,9,10), (9,10,11)]. Theses 6 subsequences have the same length equal to time_step, so it can be reshaped to 3D tensor (6, 3, 1) without padding s1 and s2 into same length. If all the sequences length are greater than the time_step, then we don’t need to pad the sequences into same length. Am I right?
Padding is only required if the number of time steps differ and/or if obs for a time step are missing.
Hi, thanks for the great article!
Say I have a normalized 2D array data with a shape of (10,2)
but when I want to reshape the data to a 3D array of (10,3,2), I got an error saying:
“ValueError: cannot reshape array of size 20 into shape (10,3,2)”
It seems that the previous 2D array multiply the samples of data of 10 with the input dimensions of 2 before reshaping it to a 3D array, and perhaps that caused the error?
Thanks in advance,
You need more data to go from (10,2) to (10,3,2), think about it, maybe even draw a pic of it. You are invention dimensions that don’t exist in your original data.
You would beed (10,6) to go to (10,3,2)
Ok I think I got it, I should actually divide the samples with the timesteps, because doing this finally solved my problem! Thanks Jason!
Ok I see. So, does reframed first the data with lagged t-n solved the issue?
If you may I Have a Question : I Have 20 Topics (classes) each topic have 700 files each file is a represent a document but in word embedding representation (size of each file : number of words X 300 features ) I want to train a LSTM Network is it possible and how ?
You can get started with LSTMs and text data here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/start-here/#nlp
Thank you so much I will look it up …
I have another question please, so for my problem does your book “Deep Learning for Natural Language Processing” have LSTM in it because I don’t only want to take the word embedding only but I want to take word’s order in consideration .
or I’ll need your book “Long Short-Term Memory Networks With Python” also ?
Sorry for bothering you with my questions but I’m really stuck and I don’t have anyone who can help me in this matter.
Thanks in advance…
Best Regards,
I give examples of addressing NLP problems with LSTMs as well as other networks like MLPs and CNNs in “deep learning for nlp”.
Thanks, Jason, for your wonderful blog posts!
I have a question regarding the input shape which I cannot find a solid answer to. I don’t know how much this question is related to this blog post, but would appreciate to hear your answer to my question:
I have a training set which contains sequences of images (say n is the number of the images in the sequence and c, h, w are channel , height, and width). I have trained a CNN-LSTM on that with the input shape of (n,c,h,w).
Now, for predicting through this network, it seems I have to feed sequences of data to it at each time (not a single frame). That is, with each new frame I need to update the sequence and feed it to the network to get the results.
However, I was under the impression that when dealing with RNN or LSTM, we can feed one frame at a time (because of recurrency), rather than feeding the whole sequence. Was this impression wrong?
So, briefly, when having an LSTM network for real time prediction, do we need to feed sequences to the network, or are there cases that we may feed a single signal/frame/datapoint?
Thanks a lot in advance!
Yes, you can feed one frame of video at a time and have the CNN interpret the frames, then the LSTM put the sequence together and interpret them all.
I have an example of this in my LSTM book. I have a summary of how to do this in Keras here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/cnn-long-short-term-memory-networks/
Thanks! I went through your other blog post before (and now again). But still I don’t see how I can feed one frame at a time. How about the input size?
Do you mean I can have a CNN and a seperate LSTM. Feed frames one at a time to CNN and then in a sequence to LSTM? This means, again, I have to create the sequence myself to feed to the network?
What I don’t understand is that the input-shape of the trained network is defined to be (n, c, h, w), how can I feed an input of shape (1,c,h,w) when n is not 1?
By the way, I have already wrapped my CNN in TimeDistributed layer. my code is as below
model.add(TimeDistributed(Conv2D(24, (5, 5), padding=’same’, activation=’relu’, kernel_constraint = maxnorm(3), kernel_initializer=’he_normal’), input_shape=(5,1, 125, 150)))
model.add(TimeDistributed(MaxPooling2D(pool_size=(2, 2), strides = (2,2))))
model.add(TimeDistributed(Dropout(0.4)))
model.add(TimeDistributed(Conv2D(36, (5, 5), activation=’relu’, padding=’same’, kernel_constraint=maxnorm(3))))
model.add(TimeDistributed(MaxPooling2D(pool_size=(2, 2), strides = (2,2))))
model.add(TimeDistributed(Dropout(0.6)))
model.add(TimeDistributed(Conv2D(50, (5, 5), padding=’same’, activation=’relu’, kernel_constraint = maxnorm(3))))
model.add(TimeDistributed(MaxPooling2D(pool_size=(2, 2), strides = (2,2))))
model.add(TimeDistributed(Dropout(0.4)))
model.add(TimeDistributed(Conv2D(70, (5, 5), padding=’same’, activation=’relu’, kernel_constraint = maxnorm(3))))
model.add(TimeDistributed(MaxPooling2D(pool_size=(2, 2), strides = (2,2))))
model.add(TimeDistributed(Dropout(0.5)))
model.add(TimeDistributed(Flatten()))
# define LSTM model
model.add(LSTM(128, return_sequences=True))
model.add(LSTM(32))
model.add(Dense(2, activation=’sigmoid’))
No, it is one model. The size to the CNN is the size of one image. Images are exposed to the model in a sequence, something like:
[samples, frames, width, height, channels]
Thanks, Jason, for your wonderful post!
I created a model before to read your post, and I see that I made a mistake. I swapped time step by feature. How much this can impact in model performance?
Best regards!
The model learns over time. Time is key to the models understanding of the sequence.
Hi, thanks for the great article 🙂
One thing I did’t understand on LSTM network-
If the output of each time step suppose to predict the next input,
how come that the input vector dimension (witch related to the features number) not equal to output vector dimension (witch related to the number of units in the layer)
Other way around.
The output at one step may be used as input at the next step.
Perhaps this will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/convert-time-series-supervised-learning-problem-python/
Hi Jason,
Many thanks for the post – it was really useful!
I would just like to run my problem through with you just to verify you feel the approach outlined in this tutorial is suitable for me:
I have two columns of data – one is resonance energies and the other is corresponding neutron widths. I want to feed 70% of this data to the network i.e values of resonance energies and neutron neutrons. Then ask the network to predict the neutron width values given the remaining 30% unseen resonance energies.
I wanted an LSTM layer as it may help use previous computations in its current prediction.
So I believe I have 2 inputs and one output.
If i have 300 values of [resonance energies, neutron widths] (i.e 300 rows of data) would my reshape be:
reshape(1, 300, 2) or reshape(1, 300, 1) ? I’m not sure if the second column is technically a feature as its meant to be the output.
Also would i need any explicit pairing given each resonance energy is related to the neutron width on the same row? Or should i use some key-value pair?
(This is also the first experiment, I also hope to then use resonance energy and neutron width to predict another variable but essentially in exactly the same way as described in this problem just the new experiment contains one more feature)
It sounds like you have 300 time steps of 1 input feature.
You could have one sample of [1,300,1] but that would not be enough to train a model.
Perhaps you can split the input samples into smaller subsequences of 5 or 10 time steps?
Perhaps this worked example will make things clearer for you:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/prepare-univariate-time-series-data-long-short-term-memory-networks/
Thank you very much for the swift reply.
Ah my data is here
https://pastebin.com/index/9qwJU3AQ
I have read the link you provided however I am unclear as to whether my data allows me to drop the time variable as mentioned in your article. If so, I could perhaps have the sample of [1,300,1] as opposed to [1,300,2]
One query I have is I’m getting a score of ‘Test Score: 0.00 MSE (0.01 RMSE)” for my test set (which is 30% of my samples) would not having enough samples really be shown by such low RMSE scores? If anything doesn’t that show the predictions are almost too good (or overfitting)?
Sorry one final thing from reading this tutorial – If one uses an LSTM layer, is it still possible to use look_back? (an argument used quite frequently in your other tutorials when creating a dataset). If I am correct, an LSTM layer essentially allows for previous calculations to be examined when determining the current calculation, but look_back determines how many previous timesteps can be consider at each timestep calculation?
I do not have the capacity to shape the data for you. I believe you have everything you need to shape your data for an LSTM model.
A look-back refers to the number of prior time steps of data to feed to the model in one sample. E.g. the “timesteps” in [samples, timesteps, features].
Hi Jason,
Sure that sounds good I will have a go at that.
One quick question I had is when I plot my results in many of your tutorial you tend to use the lines:
testPredictPlot = numpy.empty_like(dataset)
testPredictPlot[:, :] = numpy.nan
testPredictPlot[len(trainPredict)+(look_back)+1:len(dataset)-1, :] = testPredict
so the first line simply creates the numpy matrix like dataset,
but does the second line fill it with nan values? (if so why, or is it just a check?)
The third line then shift the test predict plot?
Many thanks
You’re explanation seems correct.
Hi Jason,
Thank you for this post. I’ve learned a lot from it.
I have a question about my LSTM model for classification.
My input data is 4842 samples, 34 time steps, 254 features. In other words, it’s (4842,34,254).
I have trained it with proper parameters. Although I got a decent result with 98% accuracy on validation data, I got pretty low accuracy at around 20% on test data (from separate data).
My first thought is overfitting but I also tried callback function such as earlystopping or reducelronplateau. It does not give me a better result.
Could you give me any suggestions on this issue?
Many thanks!
Yes, sounds like overfitting.
I have a suite of ideas here to try:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/improve-deep-learning-performance/
Hi Jason,
I learn a lot from your blog posts. For this specific post, I have three specific questions.
Q1: How do we decide the value of FIRST parameter of the constructor LSTM. You used LSTM (32, …). How was that value of 32 decided for the representative problem that is being addressed here? For word embedding input, is a vlaue between 200 and 500 reasonable?
Q3: What is the significane of this parameter? Is it number of LSTM cells and should it be matched with the value of dimension of input layer of the Keras model (in case of work embedding, value b/w 200 and 500)?
Q3: What would be perfformance impact of choosing a value of 500 for this parameter?
Thanks and Regards
The number of nodes in the first hidden layer is found via trial and error or tuning, more here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/how-many-layers-and-nodes-do-i-need-in-my-neural-network
I just don’t understand reshape. I do not see how you calculate the array and enter it to batch size or train data on it. I have been stuck on this all day and googling. Any help from anyone is greatly appreciated
Perhaps go back to basics and learn how to use the reshape function:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/index-slice-reshape-numpy-arrays-machine-learning-python/
hello Jason, thanks for your great explanation
can you help me with this question:
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/52317804/recurrent-neural-network-using-different-time-steps-with-keras
Perhaps you can summarize it for me in a sentence?
Hi Jason,
I have multidimensional timeseries data with a sample size of 200,000 and 50 dimensions.
I want to train a sequence to sequence autoencoder on normal data to use it later to detect anomalies. I want to have a go at this task using a LSTM autoencoder, using the example from the keras site:
https://blog.keras.io/building-autoencoders-in-keras.html
inputs = Input(shape=(timesteps, input_dim))
encoded = LSTM(latent_dim)(inputs)
decoded = RepeatVector(timesteps)(encoded)
decoded = LSTM(input_dim, return_sequences=True)(decoded)
sequence_autoencoder = Model(inputs, decoded)
encoder = Model(inputs, encoded)
I am confused about how to convert my data.
When generating the sequences lets say with a timestep of 100: do I convert this 200k data into separate sequences of 100, or use a sliding window to generate my sequences?
Many thanks for your help.
Yes, you split the long sequence into subsequences.
No need to overlap, but you can if you want and see if it improves detection.
Hi Jason,
Excellent tutorial. I have a question that I wanted to ask.
I have a total of 3 sequences.
Sequence 1: It has a shape of 800×2500 (800 observations and 2500 features) It falls into category 1
Sequence 2: It has a shape of 1000×2500. It falls into category 2
Sequence 3: It has a shape of 600×2500. It falls into category 3.
I have combined these 3 sequences into 1 array which has 2400×2500 features. I want to train an LSTM network on this array. Want it to learn pattern of these sequences and predict the category (1,2 r 3) given a new test sequence of any length (? x 2500) shape.
What should my input shape be? Should it be (1,2400,2500)?
Each sequence would be a separate sample and the number of time steps would have to be padded with zeros to match.
The shape would be: [3, 1000, 2500]
Training a model on 3 samples does not sound useful, you might need 3 thousand or 3 million samples.
Also, 1000 time steps might be a little long, 200-400 is preferred.
model.fit(trainX,trainY,epochs=100,verbose=0)
ValueError: Error when checking input: expected lstm_2_input to have shape (3, 1) but got array with shape (1, 1) this error occur
I have some suggestions here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/why-does-the-code-in-the-tutorial-not-work-for-me
Hi Jason,
thank you so much for this tutorial. I have a question conserning Conv2D
i want to devlop model for binery image classification with size (256*256)
i put my image in liste numpy with lenth (10000) and each index have np.array (256*256)
i get error when i start fit the model with input_shape = (256,256,1)
what i should define input shape
thank you
A 2D CNN will require input with the shape: rows x cols x channels. [256,256,1] sounds right.
Hello, thank you for your tutorials.
I am trying to understand data inputs to LSTM autoencoder, but I am lost.
I want use autoencoder for anomaly detection in time series (falling detection).
Dataset:
500 samples (data from gyroscope – walking, jumping, running…)
600-10000 time steps in each sample (6-100seconds).
3 features.
Example of one sample(one file):
time x y z
1 1.3 9.6 1.3
2 1.2 9.3 1.5
3 0.9 8.0 -2
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
1000 1.4 9.8 2
Idea:
Train autoencoder to reproduce normal data(walking,jumping,running…).
Anomaly detection: Reproduction error.
I want to check anomaly (fall) in 2second time windows(200 time steps) -> Reproduce every 2second window and check reproduction error.
Questions:
Can you please explain how to prepare dataset for this task?(dimensions, structure of dataset…)
How big batches and time steps(seq_length) shoud I use?
Should I generate batches randomly, or from start of dataset? (batch1: 0 – batch_size, batch2: batch_size-batch_size*2 …) -> I saw that someone generated random batches in every iteration. Couldn’t that cause some data to be used multiple times and others is not used at all?
Thank you.
I have an example of preparing activity recognition data or an LSTM here that might be useful:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/how-to-model-human-activity-from-smartphone-data/
Hello, thanks a lot for this tutorial. I’m working on some project but still stuck after reading this. Here’s the description
I have a dataframe of 2 columns, both text – one is title and other is the label to it.
Unique label count is around 40k so one hot encode was out of question.
I used word2vec with size=150 for both, trained and used the created model to encode both title and label.
e.g. for hello world
I split them and then use their respective word vectors of size 150, add them and normalize to create a vector that represents hello world.
So both columns in my dataframe had been changed and each column of each row has a vector.
dataframe.shape shows (len, 2) where len is length of dataframe
and then I did
X = df[‘title’].values
y = df[‘label’].values
and I got two numpy.ndarray with following shapes
X.shape –> (len,)
X[0].shape –> (150,)
y.shape –> (len,)
y[0].shape –> (150,)
After this I’m stuck with input and output shapes for the network.
I tried with LSTM and I got the error that lstm expected 3 dimensions but got array
I tried with Dense layers and still got shape errors.
Basically I’m struggling as to what the input and output should be for the network.
Any help in this regard is appreciated. I can provide more details and code if needed.
What do you mean you used word2vec for the label? Does that mean you are predicting a vector that is then mapped to words? Sounds odd.
I would recommend an embedding on the front end and softmax on the output with 40k one hot encoded vectors.
hi jason, thank you for the tutorial.
I am trying to feed 3 column(3316 rows) merged encoded text Train_data and Train_Labels categorizing class 1-9(3316 rows) to an lstm network.
Train_input last column is output of word embedded vector of 50 dimensions,(3316,50)
Train_input first and second columns are words – one-hot encoded text data (3316,2)
After merging three columns the shape is (samples=1, time_steps=3316, features=3)
TraIN_LABELS categorizing above train_data into class 1-9. encoded it using label encoder.
train_input=(1,3316,3), train_label=(1,3316,9) facing error with this data shape
reshaping labels to (1,3316,3) is not happening
how do i reshape labels to feed to lstm?
The labels are typically a 1D array with one element per input sample.
Thank you for the reply jason.
LSTM network returned error as “expecting dense 3dimensional shape instead recieved
(3316,)” when given 1D array.
Is there any other way that i can feed? Have i done any mistake in reshaping train data?
Really appreciated your explanation!
Could you explain how to feed multi-input the LSTM, let’s say:
you have: data = data.reshape(1, 10, 2)
data = array([
[0.1, 1.0],
[0.2, 0.9],
[0.3, 0.8],
[0.4, 0.7],
[0.5, 0.6],
[0.6, 0.5],
[0.7, 0.4],
[0.8, 0.3],
[0.9, 0.2],
[1.0, 0.1]])
and model.add(LSTM(32, input_shape=(10, 2)))
So in1 iteration of epoch, the value in the first column: 0.1,0.2,….. 1.0 will be fed into xt, xt+1,…, xt+9 of input gate of LSTM. And the 2nd column: 1.0, 0.9…0.1, will they be also fed into xt,xt+1,…,xt+9 or they will fed into another input gate of LSTM: xxt, xxt+1,….,xxt+9 ?
Not quite, if there is 1 sample, and your batch size is 1 sample, then all time steps in the 1 input sample will be fed into the model for epoch 1.
Sorry, I am still not clear !
So model.add(LSTM(32, input_shape=(10, 2)))
what is the number 2 in the input_shape(10,2) mean ?
(10,2) means that each sample will have 10 timesteps with 2 features.
Hello Jason, thanks a lot for your great post.
I had understood the post and made a dataset as follow.
x_train_shape : (35849, 100, 3)
y_train_shape : (35849, )
x_validation_shape : (8963, 100, 3)
y_validation_shape : (8963, )
x_train_shape : (11204, 100, 3)
y_train_shape : (11204, )
It is a time series sensor data of three-channel.
And, the actual form of the data is as follow.
(2067, 1976, 1964)
(2280, 1994, 1952)
(2309, 1976, 1968)
.
.
.
(2020, 2160, 1979)
(1994, 2181, 2064)
I did labeling the data for particular section by [window size : 100, stride : 15] per a channel.
For example, if the particular section is from 251 to 750, 27 pieces of cutted-data are made as follows.
251~350, 266~365, 281~380, …, 641~740
With this data, I was able to proceed learning with DFN and CNN to perform effectively.
However, when I do learning using LSTM, the learning does not proceed that the loss does not decrease and the accuracy is around 50%.
So I would like to hear your opinion about this phenomenon, which has a broad and deep knowledge in this field.
Should I change the data structure differently?
Or, is there a particular LSTM-containing model structure suitable for data like this structure?
Or, do you have another new opinion?
Thank you so much for your interest in my problem.
LSTMs are generally poor a time series forecasting. You may need to carefully tune the model.
Thank you for your reply.
Last night, I was contemplating a lot. I was able to figure out why my dataset is not suitable for this model.
This is because a unit of data cannot affect the decision.
So I’m going to find a way to increase the data processing unit on LSTM.
I have been able to think a lot through your material and reply.
Thank you so much again.
Nice work.
Hi,
I am really confused with Input shape. Assume I have a data set of some info about houses.
Features are [size, room_no, floor_no]
My data set contains 4 samples as follow:
dataX = [[200, 3, 1], [150, 1, 1], [270, 4, 2], [320, 3, 2]]. Which for example dataX[0] is house number0 with size of 200, 3 rooms and 1 floor.
Now I want to train my LSTM. Are (samples, time_step, feature) different from the ones I defined here? I mean I have 4 samples with 3 features! How do you tell that to LSTM? For example would you please say that in the first 2 or 3 time steps what data is fed into LSTM?
Thank you very much. 🙂
Each of size, rooms and floor are “features”. Features=3
If you have 3 houses, these are “samples”. Samples=3
But you did not mention any time steps. If you have no time steps (observations over time), an LSTM is a poor choice and I would recommend an MLP instead.
Hello Jason,
First of all, thanks for all your work. It is grateful to have a support like you give us in all your tutorials!
On the other hand, I have a question. For LSTMs we need a 3D array (samples, features, timesteps). But I still don’t understand what “timesteps” means? Is it the same of loop_back variable?
Thanks,
Time steps are observations (features) made over time (e.g. minutes, hours, etc.). Or, they can be items in a sequence like words in a sentence.
Does that help?
Like others, I wanna say thank you for this and other useful articles.
I need to connect output of ConvLSTM2D to a LSTM!
The output of ConvLSTM2D is (samples, time, output_row, output_col, filters) which return_sequences is True.
I’m confused here how this 5-D input can be feed to a LSTM!
I will be thankful if any help!
Are you sure the output of the ConvLSTM2D is as you describe?
If so, perhaps you can use a lambda to flatten rows/cols and filters.
Hello Jason,
I have a dataframe of n,p rows (n for the different samples and p for q timesteps and r static feature p = q+r ). For each row, I have q values for the measure of interest and r static features.
Basically, I want to do a time series classification that is based also on the static features.
From what I understood, the input shape should be (n,q,r) but I cannot transform my dataframe from (n,p) to (n,q,r) since p = q+r
Thank you a lot for your help !
I don’t follow what you mean by p = q+r?
Dear Jason,
why do we need to reshape the data in numpy before feeding the data to the lstm. Why Keras doesn’t do it automatically?
if I have a sequence of 10 values and I want to predict the 11th value, I guess Keras LSTM has already all the information in a numpy array of size (1,10) to answer the task of predicting the 11th value . Why do I need to reshape it to (1,10,1) ?
regards
Guido
Why – that is the expectation of the API. Don’t fight it, meet it.
Hi Jason,
Thank you for your great post.
I have problem about padding.
I use the pre-trained sentence embedding(dim:300),
and 1 sample means a document in my application.
Now I have variable sentence number in documents.
(Not sentence sequences with variable words length)
E.g., doc1:[sent1, sent2]
doc2:[sent1]
doc3:[sent1, sent2, sent3]
The zero-padding in variable sentence sequences means pad 0 after sequence of word_index
But pre-trained sentence embedding can’t map sentence to index
How do I pad the sentence number to a fixed size?
Does it just pad 300 zeros in each timestep, and use mask layer to skip those zeros?
E.g., pad_sent = np.zeros((1,300))
doc1:[sent1, sent2, pad_sent]
doc2:[sent1, pad_sent, pad_sent]
doc3:[sent1, sent2, sent3]
Thank you.
The padded values can be mapped to the index of “unknown” in the embedding, which is often also 0.
Hi Jason Hopefully you have not already answered this. To prep the x data for LSTM input,
the data is reshaped to a 3 d array. Should something similiar also be done to the y data? Should it also be divided up into subsequences so that the output is synced up with the input?
If so, should that be done prior to transforming the data with one hot encoding? Or does the
one hot encoding come after? Thanks for all your help.
No, not unless you are predicting a sequence output.
If you are predicting a multi-class label, a one hot encoding is used.
Hi Jason,
great article – always come here when needed a boiled-down explanation. Thank you!
Regarding input shapes – have been using LSTM for a while and didn’t have any problems with it but now I tried 1D convolutional layers for speeding up processing and now I run into trouble – can you see what the problem is with the following? (Dummy data used here)
#load packages
import numpy as np
import pandas as pd
from keras.models import Sequential
from keras.layers import Dense, Dropout, Activation, GRU, TimeDistributed
from keras.layers import Conv1D, MaxPooling1D, Flatten, GlobalAveragePooling1D
from keras.layers import Conv2D, MaxPooling2D
from keras.utils import np_utils
nfeat, kernel, timeStep, length, fs = 36, 8, 20, 100, 100
#data (dummy)
data = np.random.rand(length*fs,nfeat)
classes = 0*data[:,0]
classes[:int(length/2*fs)] = 1
#splitting matrix
#data
X = np.asarray([data[i*timeStep:(i + 1)*timeStep,:] for i in range(0,length * fs // timeStep)])
#classes
Y = np.asarray([classes[i*timeStep:(i + 1)*timeStep] for i in range(0,length * fs // timeStep)])
#split into training and test set
from sklearn.model_selection import train_test_split
trainX, testX, trainY, testY = train_test_split(X,Y,test_size=0.2,random_state=0)
#one-hot-encoding
trainY_OHC = np_utils.to_categorical(trainY)
trainY_OHC.shape, trainX.shape
#set up model with simple 1D convnet
model = Sequential()
model.add(Conv1D(8,10,activation=’relu’,input_shape=(timeStep,nfeat)))
model.add(MaxPooling1D(3))
model.add(Flatten())
model.add(Dense(10,activation=’tanh’))
model.add(Dense(2,activation=’softmax’))
model.summary()
#compile model
model.compile(loss=’mse’,optimizer=’Adam’ ,metrics=[‘accuracy’])
#train model
model.fit(trainX,trainY_OHC,epochs=5,batch_size=4,validation_split=0.2)
I get an error for the fitting:
ValueError: Error when checking target: expected dense_17 to have 2 dimensions, but got array with shape (400, 20, 2)
I cannot see what is wrong here?!
I suspect your output variable y does not match the expectation of the model of 2 values per sample. Instead, you’ve provided [400,20,2]
Hello Jason,
Thanks for the tutorial. Your tutorials are a life-saver! I have a simple doubt.
I have extracted speech features from 597 .wav files into arrays. Each array is of shape Nx40, where N varies between 500-1100. In other words, for each of the 597 .wav files, I have an array of N rows (varying between 500-1100) and 40 columns (40 acoustic features).
1. So, what should be my 3D input shape to the LSTM? Is it (1, ?, 40), where ? = N.
2. If it is (1, ?, 40), then should I pick a particular length and pad the rest of them?
Really stuck with this. Any response will be of immense help. Thanks!
Sounds like you have nearly 600 samples, 500-1100 time steps and about 40 features.
I’d recommend padding the time steps and having a shape of something like [600, 1100, 40] as a start, then try truncating time steps to see how it impacts the model.
Hey Jason,
I have a Time series dataset for 38,000 distinct patients, where each patient has 30 physiological parameters recorded for an hour. If I want to extract 48 hours of information of a patient for every hour, then technically I’ll have 48 rows for a single patient, every row containing observations for 30 feature for every hour! suppose I want to extract similar data for the other 29,000 patients, then ill end up with over a lakh rows i.e(29,000 * 48 rows). So should my input shape be (30,000, 48, 30) ?
Maybe, I’m not sure I follow about “48 hours every hour”. Perhaps try your approach?
What should be the output layer shape? Particularly, if I have only one sample, do I need to reshape it into three dimensions? For example, if I have the input data of shape [m,n] and output also has [m,n] shape. Do I need to change the input into [m,1,n] shape? Also, can I keep the output shape [m,n] if I am using return_sequences=False? I am dealing with time series data. Below are the input and output at different time steps for example
Input: Output:
[1,2] [3,4]
[2,3] [4,5]
[4,5] [6,7]
Thank you
Output shape is often [samples, features] for a normal model or [sample, time steps, features] for an encoder-decoder model.
Hi Jason,
Your article is so good. I want to apply this to my data set.
I have 3000 samples and 88 features(columns).In that number of feature columns, I have 20 features called A, B, C, D etc.For each one of them I have 3 columns A1,A2,A3 , B1,B2,B3 , C1,C2,C3 etc as lag columns. Thus 20+20*3 = 80 are the feature columns with lags
and 8 other features which do not have lag values.
How to convert that into a shape of 3D array to feed as input to LSTM model?
Your reply is greatly appreciated.
Good question, this will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
hi jason
I want to write code for functionalities of input gate ,output gate and forget gate for LSTM.help me sir
Sorry, I don’t have an example of coding an LSTM cell from scratch, thanks for the suggestion.
sir,
directly we are using LSTM function to process the data .instead we can write the code for input gate ,forget gate and output gate by creating own lstm function
I recommend using Keras and not coding an LSTM from scratch as it will almost certainly have bugs and be less efficient.
Hi
Thanks so much for this, your stuff is really helping me get my head around LSTMs
I’m struggling to understand how to load more than just one sample though. This works fine:
samples = np.array([
[0.1, 1.0],
[0.2, 0.9],
[0.3, 0.8],
[0.4, 0.7],
[0.5, 0.6],
[0.6, 0.5],
[0.7, 0.4],
[0.8, 0.3],
[0.9, 0.2],
[1.0, 0.1]])
samples = samples.reshape(1, 10, 2)
But how should I present my data to use something with (2,10,2) or (3,10,2)? Is it an array of arrays?
Ultimately I want to be able to go from an hdf5 file to a numpy array to this 3d shape, but I’m struggling to tell my model that there is more than one sample, even when i’m just making up and typing the data as a toy example. Any tips?
Load more data into memory, then reshape it.
Perhaps I don’t understand the problem you’re having.
Also, this may help with mindset:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
I don’t think I explained it very well. Thanks for taking the time to reply. I think my question is what should my data look like if I have more than one sample and I’m trying to use reshape?
What I mean is at the moment ‘samples’ is a numpy array representing just one example of 2 features and 10 timesteps. when really, samples should be a dataset of many examples. And I don’t understand how to write that so that it can be reshaped. Should samples be a list of numpy arrays. or does it need to be an array of arrays or something else? I’ve tried both but neither seems to work.
Reading this https://machinelearningmastery.com/gentle-introduction-n-dimensional-arrays-python-numpy/ suggests it could be that i need to use vstack?
Yes, a vstack, dstack or hstack will do it.
I cannot know, I don’t have your code/data and it is completely specific to your data.
If you’re having trouble, try tinkering with a few contrived samples in a separate python file until you get it right.
Hi!
I have a df like this https://imgur.com/a/hmg2Ng4
If I want use temporal component for a LSTM, i think that my sequence, will be make by date_col.
But, If I select date_col, I will have a array of new information. I mean, it’s not a row typical secuence, I think this is more complex.
My secuence will be [day1,day2,day3] and, in each day, I have a array with [product1,product2,product3], and each product [feat1, feat2].
For day 1: [[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2]]
Secuence will be:
[ [[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2]],
[[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2]],
[[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2],[feat1,feat2]] ]
This is correct? This will work with neural networks?
I’m seeing that I’m writing so bad.
‘My secuence will be [day1,day2,day3] and, in each day, I have a array with [product1,product2,product3], and each product [feat1, feat2]. ‘
when I say productX, i want to say idX
Perhaps.
I think this explanation will help you develop an intuition for data prep with LSTMs:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hi Jason. Thank you for your informative articles. They have been very helpful to me.
I was wondering if you could give me your recommendation on setting up a LSTM model. I’m dealing with three features that are measured when a passive RFID tag is read by an RFID reader. I understand that before setting up my model, I need to decide how many time steps I will be dealing with for each input. Let’s say I set that number at 32 time steps. This means my input shape will be (32, 3). What I’m not clear on is if I need to add a feature for a time stamp of when that read occurred. Tag reads can happen at any rate. There could be one read per second which would mean my input instance of (32, 3) would span 32 seconds, or there could be one read per minute which would mean my input instance of (32, 3) would span 32 minutes. Most importantly, the read rate will not be constant. I could get 3 reads in 1 second and then wait 30 seconds for the fourth read to come in.
Does the LSTM need to know about this, or is it enough to simply give it the time ordered sequence of reads without it knowing the actual time span those 32 reads occurred over?
If I did have to add a time stamp to my data, the input shape would now be (32, 4). As a follow up question, does the LSTM require me to define a fixed time step between the feature inputs? What I mean is, am I forced to pick a time span of say 1 second between the input feature list? If I am, and I only have reads at time 0 seconds, 4 seconds, and 6 seconds, do I then have to generate my (32, 4) input values as follows:
(0, x0, y0, z0)
(1, missing, missing, missing)
(2, missing, missing, missing)
(3, missing, missing, missing)
(4, x4, y4, z4)
(5, missing, missing, missing)
(6, x6, y6, z6)
…..
OR
is there no assumption needed on the time between inputs so I can I simply stack them without inserting missing values, such as:
(0, x0, y0, z0)
(4, x4, y4, z4)
(6, x6, y6, z6)
Any input you can provide would be appreciated.
Thank you.
Perhaps try modeling as-is, then try with padded/missing values and see if there is any difference in model skill.
Also try other model types. LSTMs are mostly terrible at time series.
Thanks Jason. I was surprised to hear you say LSTM’s are terrible at time series. What I’m trying to implement is a binary sequence classification model using the setup I described above. If you think LSTM’s are not the right approach given what I’ve described, what type of model do you think would work best? I want to process the data as new reads come in and give a classification output every time I get a new read.
I was planning to use your post on: Sequence Classification with LSTM Recurrent Neural Networks in Python with Keras as my starting point, but now you’ve got me concerned I’m going down the wrong path.
LSTMs can be good for time series classification.
In general, I recommend this process:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/how-to-develop-a-skilful-time-series-forecasting-model/
Hi,Jason. I want add a dense layer before LSTM layer, but don’t know how to reshape the data. The input data (train_x) is 3D (batch_size,time_step,input_dim), I firstly want to reshape the data to 2D so as to apply to dense layer,.After operating the dense layer ,I have to reshape the 2D outcome of dense layer to 3D so as to apply in the LSTM layer. I am using keras function API, but I can not find a reshape layer to do that (keras.layers.reshape can not do that.).Do you have any idea?
A dense layyer cannot take 3d data as input, it must be [samples, features].
So I want to transform the shape of data, maybe this is not a correct idea.
But thank you very much for your patient help.
Hi Jason, when you write: “How to reshape multiple parallel series data for an LSTM model and define the input layer”
Does this statement refer to text + tag data, for example text data with parallel IOB (inside – outside – begin) tags for named entity recognition? For example:
Alex I-PER
is O
going O
to O
Los B-LOC
Angeles I-LOC
If you are talking about something different in this article, do you have another article on preparing data for such parallel text sequences?
The example generally refers to sequences of numbers.
For encoding words in a vocab, I recommend starting here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/start-here/#nlp
I don’t have an example of working with tag data, sorry.
Hi Jason,
I’m kind of confused about the part of model.add(LSTM(32)). Does the number 32 represent 32 neurons? or more specifically, 32 memory cells for LSTM?
Thanks
Steven
Yes, 32 is the number of units in the hidden layer. Each unit in the first hidden layer receives all of the inputs.
Hi Jason,
I am working on project for crime prediction. I have a dataset containning row as date(timestamp) and columns as area(features). Each cell contains count of crimes happened in particular area.
Total no of rows = 1825 days of crime counts per area or 5 years
here is the dataset.
date\ Area 111 112 113 114
0 5 2 2 0
1 3 3 9 0
2 5 4 8 0
3 4 4 3 0
4 9 11 9 0
I want to use sliding window to forecast which will take 100 days as input and predict
101th day output i.e. crime count for each area.
Here, I wiil consider first 3 rows(0-2) as input and predict output i.e. 4th row(3)
I will be shifting dataframe by -3
Questions:
1) what is X_train shape, y_train shape?
(1,1825,4)
here samples = 1(?), timesteps = 1825 rows, features = 4 columns
Am I correct?
What is exactly sample?
2) model.add(LSTM(4, batch_input_shape=(1,1825,1),
activation=’relu’,return_sequences=True,))
What will be input of batch_input_shape [Batch_size, sequence_length, features]??
Should batch_input_shape be same as X_train shape??
sequence_length
I have wasted 2 days trying find out what is the relation between these two.
PLESE HELP.
Perhaps start with this post to prepare the sliding window:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/convert-time-series-supervised-learning-problem-python/
Then here to better understand how to reshape the sliding window to 3d:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hello Jason, thanks for your tutorial,
I have a question, I have a Time series dataset for about 38.000 patients, where each patient has 38 physiological parameters recorded for one hour, and each patient has at least 25 hours of parameters recorded, for clarification:
pat1: feat1, feat2, ….. feat38, hour1, label
feat1, feat2, ….. feat38, hour2, label
………………………………,hour25, label
pat2: feat1, feat2, ….. feat38, hour1, label
feat1, feat2, …., feat38, hour2, label
………………………………,hour25, label
…….
pat38000: ….
The model should predict whether the patient has the disease or not, as early as possible.
My question is how I would shape my input array? I do not understand what the samples will be
(Samples, time-step, features) -> (?, 7 hours “for example” ?, 38) or what?
Perhaps this will further help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hi Jason ,
How does reshaping effect training / target data.
dataset = dataset.reshape(1,36,66)
train_data = dataset[:,0:32,:65]
train_targets = dataset[:,0:32,65:]
test_data = dataset[:,32:,:65]
test_targets = dataset[:,32:,65:]
def build_model():
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(32,input_shape=(32,65)))
model.add(Dense(1))
model.compile(optimizer=’rmsprop’, loss=’mse’, metrics=[‘mae’])
return model
model = build_model()
model.fit(train_data, train_targets,
epochs=30, batch_size=16, verbose=0)
test_mse_score, test_mae_score = model.evaluate(test_data, test_targets)
I get this : ValueError: Error when checking target: expected dense_40 to have 2 dimensions, but got array with shape (1, 32, 1)
If I reshape the targets
train_targets = train_targets.reshape(32,1)
test_targets = test_targets.reshape(4,1)
I get this
ValueError: Input arrays should have the same number of samples as target arrays. Found 1 input samples and 32 target samples.
Seem I can’t win. What should I be doing? Thanks
You must have one output sample for each input sample.
Hi Jason, can you please help me with reshaping data for LSTM,
I have data set with shape (4615, 9), 4618 inputs, 9 features and 3 classes (labels) to predict.
I want to reshape my data so the input shape have 5 time steps. I try to do it in this way
X = np.reshape(X, (923,5,X_train.shape[1]))
but I have got an error when try to train_test_split.
I only can make it work with one time step X_test = np.reshape(X_test, (X_test.shape[0],1,X_test.shape[1]))
🙁
Perhaps this will make things clearer:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hi Jason,
Thanks for your tutorials. I’m trying to build a hydrological model that can predict streamflow with a sample lead time of 10 days, though I’m confused as to how to shape the data. First, I assume I’d shift the x and y data to reflect the lag and end up with 355 (365-10) samples of each. Say I have 4 features – the base shape for x would be would be (355, 4). Does 355 represent the number of samples or the number of time steps? They seem as they are the same to me, though I think I need to reshape the data to either (1, 355, 4) or (355,1, 4). Or perhaps (5, 355/5, 1) – etc. Or, do I need to generate separate lagged (by 1) sequences to generate something like (100, 355, 4)?
Perhaps this will help understand the difference between samples and timesteps:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hi Jason
Do you have examples/suggestions how to use contemporaneous conditional context for time series prediction using LSTM and/or CNN (e.g. predicting next week product sales based on given price that week and history of sales and prices). The differences from multivariate prediction is that conditional context is known for the prediction week. Thanks!
You can frame the prediction problem with any inputs you wish.
Sir if I use LSTMs(Encoder Decoder model) for summarizing articles , I’ll input the sentence vector , encoder encodes them to fixed sized vectors , but I wanted to know :
1) how will the model know what keywords or sentences it must keep for summarizing , and then how does the decoder for sentences ?
2 )can I use neural language model for framing sentences back ?
but I didn’t get how to solve the (1) problem
Thanks for your blogpost!
The model will learn what words are important to preserve in the text.
I don’t understand your second question, sorry. Perhaps you can elaborate?
Sir , in simple words , can I use neural language modelling for summarizing texts with LSTMs ?
No. You can use a neural text summarization model to summarize text. A language model alone is one part of a text summarization model.
Sir , Can I use Encoder Decoder Network for Summarizing Texts ?
Yes:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/encoder-decoder-models-text-summarization-keras/
dear Sir thank you a lot for your post if you have a source code in Decision tree regression to predict Time series data
Thanks.
I don’t have a tutorial on this specific case.
From what I understand, samples are the number of rows (either the entire dataset or a subset of it) we have in a data frame; features are the independent variables (x-variables). I am confused about time steps. Is my understanding correct? I have a time series dataset of 10 features, 600 observations (rows). How do I set the input shape? Are there different ways of doing it? Thank you!
Perhaps this will make it clearer:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Thanks for your contributions Jason, I have been visiting your blog numerous times by now and they always leave me with a better understanding of concepts.
Anyway, I was wondering how to deal with each label having features being observed at an erratic interval. I have not yet found a solution how to deal with this. Maybe I’m overseeing something.
Would I have to divide the timesteps in really small intervals and set observations to 0 if not observed at that timestep? Would I compute a regular interval and add an offset feature? Or something else?
Thanks in advance.
You can normalize the shape of the data so all samples have the same shape, then use zero padding and a masking layer to ignore the padded values.
Is reshaping similar for the text classification problem? How can one reshape the input_shape when there are 30000 samples with 300 features each? Additionally, what will be the meaning of timestep here when it is not actually the time series data?
This might help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
And this:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/handle-long-sequences-long-short-term-memory-recurrent-neural-networks/
Hi jason,
Thanks a lot for your wonderful tutorial. There is one thing that i do not follow. if a have 7000 dataset (samples), that each one contains 3 time series with lenght 3000 timesteps, and now i want to do binary classification on each dataset(anomaly detection) (for each sample) using LSTM,
my question is, how do i proceed? how does my input look like? because (7000, 3000, 2) is too big for lstm .The lenght of my timeseries is huge( 3000). I have read this tutorial as well, but my problem is, that i want to use all information in my training.
https://machinelearningmastery.com/handle-long-sequences-long-short-term-memory-recurrent-neural-networks/
Second of all, each sample (data set with 2 time series) is independent from another one.
Thanks in advance
Perhaps try a dynamic RNN?
I may have an example on the blog for encoder-decoder.
Jason, Thanks for your quick reply. But could you explain with more details?
don’t we use dynamic RNN for variable length of sequences? and as i said before i want to use LSTM not RNN.
Second of all, i don’t know how my inputs should looks like (in case of large time series), if you could explain that as well, i will be thankful.
Yes, a dynamic RNN can be used for variable length input.
Yes, LSTM is an RNN. A dynamic LSTM is a dynamic RNN.
You can learn more about how to prepare inputs here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hi Jason,
Thanks again, but i have read that link you provided before. But my problem is, I know how the input for small time series in my case should look like(7000, num_time steps , 2). But in this case each of my time series has 3000 time steps (each of 7000 sample).
So, my question is how we can feed this input shape (7000, 3000,2) optimally into LSTM, because as you mentioned in one of your tutorial before, the optimum length of time series should be less that 400 time steps for LSTM. My case is Special since each of a data sets (each of 7000 sample) are independent from each other and my task is to classify them as anomaly or not anomaly, however the length of each time series is 3000 and it reduce the accuracy of the model.
Thanks a lot for your time.
Naively, you cannot. You must trim the time steps.
Or, you can, but you must use a dynamic LSTM.
Thanks a lot 🙂
Hello Sir ,
my model has the following data,
Xtrain shape : (62, 30, 100)
Ytrain shape : (62, 1, 100)
Xtrain shape : (16, 30, 100)
Ytrain shape : (16, 1, 100)
when doing,
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(units=100, return_sequences= True, input_shape=(x_train.shape[1],100)))
model.add(LSTM(units=100, return_sequences=True))
model.add(LSTM(units=100))
model.add(Dense(units=100))
I get ValueError: Error when checking target: expected dense_1 to have 2 dimensions, but got array with shape (62, 1, 100)
Please Clarify On this.
Correction :
Xtrain shape : (62, 30, 100)
Ytrain shape : (62, 1, 100)
Xtest shape : (16, 30, 100)
Ytest shape : (16, 1, 100)
You must have a 2d array for target (y), not 3d
What are lstm units like lstm(32, input-shape) ? How are these related to time steps or features or embedding ?
The number of units is unrelated from the number of input timesteps and features.
Each unit gets all input.
hi Jason,
I am new in ML and I have some confusion in the Dense layer and Dense output what is the difference between the two examples below, as shown below I put the number of features at was one to predict put example two why add dense like LSTM and output dense 32.
its very important for me can you help me
thank you.
1)
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(32, input_shape=(10, 2)))
model.add(Dense(1))
2)
model = Sequential()
model.add(Dense(32, input_shape=(16,)))
model.add(Dense(32))
The first example outputs a vector with 1 element, the second outputs a vector with 32 elements.
Hi Jason,
I a dataset that has 3 features and each feature has been represented by a 200-dimension vector.
([200d],[200d],[200d]), label.
I wonder how to reshape the data for LSTM?
Thanks
I don’t follow sorry. You mean 3 time steps and 200 features per time step.
Perhaps this will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
exactly. 3 time steps and 200 features per time step.
[0.4 0.3 …0.1],[0.56 0.22 ….0.5],[0.66 0.43..0.7] , label =+1
actually each time step has a feature in vector form. I ‘ve got an error of datatype in Keras. It expects float.
the error is ”
could not convert string to float”
Perhaps try converting the string data to float first?
If the data is numbers in string format, you can use .astype() or similar on the numpy array.
If not, perhaps look into integer encoding, one hot encoding, bag of words or even word tokenizer.
suppose I have a GRU network. I want each input in a vector format. Most
of the instances that I have seen are in integer form. What should i do
to give the gru an input in vector form?
Thanks a lot, Jason
You can, one feature vector per time step. See this:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
i had to write this code
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(4, input_shape=(1,4))
model.add(Dense(4, activation=’relu’))
model.add(Dense(1, activation=’sigmoid’)
but I have seen the following error
File “”, line 5
model.add(Dense(4, activation=’relu’))
^
SyntaxError: invalid syntax
I have some suggestions here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/why-does-the-code-in-the-tutorial-not-work-for-me
Hi Jason,
I have a dataset like this.
2000-01 x1= [1, 2, 3, 4; x2=[5, 6, 9, 8; y=[4, 6, 3, 8;
5, 6, 7, 8; 1, 6, 5, 4; 8, 5, 2, 9;
4, 6, 0, 9;] 8, 4, 3, 5;] 7, 5, 3, 6;]
2000-02 x1= [1, 6, 5, 4; x2=[5, 6, 9, 8; y=[4, 6, 3, 8;
5, 6, 7, 8; 7, 5, 3, 6; 8, 5, 2, 9;
8, 4, 3, 5;] 8, 4, 3, 5;] 5, 6, 9, 8;]
2000-03 x1= [5, 6, 5, 4; x2=[5, 6, 9, 8;
9, 6, 7, 8; 7, 5, 3, 6;
1, 4, 3, 5;] 8, 4, 3, 5;]
I want to know that whether I can predict y using LSTM and above data in 2000-03. If can, I wonder how to reshape the data for LSTM?
Thank you.
Perhaps this will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hello, Jason. Thanks for good explanation.
Could you please help to understand following questions:
1. LSTM with timestep = 1 – is it a simple MLP or it is still using hidden state / cell state? What’s state initial value in case of timestamp = 1?
2. Recommendation for LSTM autoencoder timestep selection?
Data example: index – week number, feature1 – number of visits per week, feature2 – number of holidays per week, feature3 – number of room visits.
Maybe a little similar, although the model maintains state across samples.
Try different numbers of timesteps and use what gives you the most skill.
Hi Jason,
Do you have a blog on how the shape of the input data changes at each gate of LSTM?
lets say your input shape is (1000,10,36) and it is passed to LSTM(64) then what will be the shape of output at each gate of LSTM(i.e after forget gate, input gate and output gate)
We cannot configure each gate, only the input to all nodes in a layer.
The exmaple given is wrongly re-shaped.
It shall have the shape of (2,10,1) and not (1,10,2) because there are 2 sequences with 10 time stamp observations with only 1 feature at a given time.
No. Each series becomes a separate feature for each time step.
Perhaps this will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hi Jason,
I understand how to make the 3D shape that the LSTM requires. Right now I have 200 samples of 600 timesteps and 7 features.
[200,600,7]
X_train, X_test, y_train, y_test = train_test_split(dataset,test_size = 0.30)
X_train[140,600,7]
X_test[60,600,7]
y_train[140,600,1]
y_test[60,600,1]
#Build the LSTM
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(100, input_shape=(450, 11)))
model.add(Dense(1))
model.add(Activation(‘softmax’))
model.compile(loss=’categorical_crossentropy’, optimizer=Adam(0.001), metrics[‘accuracy’])
model.summary()
model.fit(X_train,y_train, batch_size=88, epochs=40, validation_split=0.2)
I get the following error message:
ValueError: Error when checking target: expected activation_10 to have 2 dimensions, but got array with shape (140, 600, 1). I cant seem to fit the model.
Hope you can help me find my error.
You must specify the input_shape that matches your data.
I thought this matched: model.add(LSTM(100, input_shape=(450, 11)))
But you said the shape of your data is: [200,600,7]
[200,600,7]
X_train, X_test, y_train, y_test = train_test_split(dataset,test_size = 0.30)
X_train[140,600,7]
X_test[60,600,7]
y_train[140,600,1]
y_test[60,600,1]
#Build the LSTM
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(100, input_shape=(600, 7)))
model.add(Dense(1))
model.add(Activation(‘softmax’))
model.compile(loss=’categorical_crossentropy’, optimizer=Adam(0.001), metrics[‘accuracy’])
model.summary()
model.fit(X_train,y_train, batch_size=140, epochs=40, validation_split=0.2)
ValueError: Error when checking target: expected activation_10 to have 2 dimensions, but got array with shape (140, 600, 1). I cant seem to fit the model.
I still get the same value error.
The y must be 2d, not 3d.
But every sample has a 600 outputs as a label. (60,600,1)
Example
x_train(1,600,7) the first sample has 600 timesteps and 7 features that will help the neural network recognize certain patterns.
y_train(1,600,1) the 600 label’s of the first sample. Should I reshape it like this? (1,600)
The error tells you the model expects output to have a 2d shape – the error even tells you what shape it expects.
Thanks. I look through all of the examples mentioned in your blog.
https://machinelearningmastery.com/start-here/#deep_learning_time_series
It looks like I was dealing with a Multivariate LSTM of Multiple Inputs. I have one question.
# split a multivariate sequence into samples
def split_sequences(sequences, n_steps):
X, y = list(), list()
for i in range(len(sequences)):
# find the end of this pattern
end_ix = i + n_steps
# check if we are beyond the dataset
if end_ix > len(sequences):
break
# gather input and output parts of the pattern
seq_x, seq_y = sequences[i:end_ix, :-1], sequences[end_ix-1, -1]
X.append(seq_x)
y.append(seq_y)
return array(X), array(y)
# define input sequence
in_seq1 = array([10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80, 90])
in_seq2 = array([15, 25, 35, 45, 55, 65, 75, 85, 95])
out_seq = array([in_seq1[i]+in_seq2[i] for i in range(len(in_seq1))])
# convert to [rows, columns] structure
in_seq1 = in_seq1.reshape((len(in_seq1), 1))
in_seq2 = in_seq2.reshape((len(in_seq2), 1))
out_seq = out_seq.reshape((len(out_seq), 1))
# horizontally stack columns
dataset = hstack((in_seq1, in_seq2, out_seq))
# choose a number of time steps
n_steps = 3
# convert into input/output
X, y = split_sequences(dataset, n_steps)
In the example that you posted. It creates a 3D shape(7,3,2) from the original sequences of 9 rows and 2 columns.
In practice, how will it work? My idea was to give a 2D tensor(100,3) of a fixed size and as an output get (100,) 100 outputs. I believe that lstm’s predict one output by one output. right?
That means that if I want to get the 100 outputs I will need to feed the neural network with these 2D tensor(100,3) –> reshape it into a 3D shape of lets say (90,10timestemps,3 features) and concatenate all the outputs into an array untill I get 90 outputs?
Good question, you can learn about the shape of inputs to the LSTM here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
hi, Jason,
I have read your other blogs and they were very helpful for me as a beginner in machine learning. I haven’t done LSTMs before. this is my first time.
I am currently trying to train video sequence data to classify the emotions involved. However, by looking at the data I am a little confused about how to model my LSTM.
My data consists of a single feature (vector of length 8192) extracted from every 90 consecutive frames from each of 615 short video clips. the video clips are having the same sample rate.
the label for each sample (each video) is a 6 X 1 vector (6 different emotions)
I know that when I am modeling the LSTM I need not bother about 615 as it is the number of samples. but how would I deal with 90 frames?. is that the number of time steps to LSTM?
Can u please tell me how I should input the data to LSTM and input shape to LSTM?
Does
The 8192 would be features in the [samples, timesteps, features] input data.
Hi Jason
Thank you so much for your reply. I was able to build a model and compile it.
this is the model I made:
x=Input(shape=(90,8192))
lstm=LSTM(100, activation= ‘relu’)(x)
lstm = Dropout(rate = 0.5)(lstm)
output1=Dense(1, activation=’softmax’)(lstm)
output2=Dense(1, activation=’softmax’)(lstm)
output3=Dense(1, activation=’softmax’)(lstm)
output4=Dense(1, activation=’softmax’)(lstm)
output5=Dense(1, activation=’softmax’)(lstm)
output6=Dense(1, activation=’softmax’)(lstm)
model =Model(x,[output1,output2,output3,output4,output5,output6])
model.compile(optimizer=”Adam”,loss=[“binary_crossentropy”,”binary_crossentropy”,”binary_crossentropy”,”binary_crossentropy”,”binary_crossentropy”,”binary_crossentropy”],metrics=[‘accuracy’])
8192 is the shape of flattened feature output from InceptionV3 for each of the frames in the video.
Shape of Y_train = (543,6,1)
the problem now I am facing is that my model accuracy does not go beyond 30.
I tried adding a dense layer of different shapes before the softmax unit, also tried with different lstm unit shapes as well. changing the batch size or optimizer is also not improving accuracy.
Can you please look into my model and help me out with where I am making the mistake.
I also tried changing the Dropout rate
Well done.
Perhaps some of the methods here will help you debug and improve model performance:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/start-here/#better
Hi Jason,
Thank you for your continued, top-class posts. I’ve a question in reshaping the dimension of the training data for LSTM. My data has 11 features and 544 observations. If I set timesteps = 1, my samples are 544/1 = 544 and the dimensions of data are correctly set to: dim(data) = c(544, 1, 11). However, when I set the timestep to, say, 7 and samples to 544/7, the dimensions of data aren’t set by dim(data) = c(544/7, 7, 11) and I get the error:
dims [product 5929] do not match the length of the object [5984].
Based on one of your FAQs, I assumed that the samples X timesteps = number of rows in the data. Can you please advise what am I doing wrong here?
Thanks,
Rahul
You’re welcome.
Setting timesteps to 1 seems like a strange move.
This will help disentangle timesteps vs samples:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Thank you for your reply. I did follow this link and got an idea that for non-intersecting blocks of observations, samples X timesteps = number of rows in the data. Since my data is daily time series and I want to treat each row as one training instance or sample, I kept the timesteps = 1 and hence, the samples = 544/1 = 544. However, if I wish to change the timesteps to any other value, I get the error as mentioned in my earlier post.
Perhaps the function described in this tutorial will help you prepare your data:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/convert-time-series-supervised-learning-problem-python/
Thank you, Jason, for the reply.
You’re welcome.
Hi Jason,
Can you please clarify how to reshape the data in R using the dim() function so that it matches the LSTM requirement? If I add the 3rd dimension, is it the timesteps? Besides, why is the number of timesteps = 1 a strange move? I’ll be obliged for your help.
Sorry, I don’t have examples of LSTMs in R. Perhaps try posting your question on stackoverflow?
Great guidance.
Clear and simple.
Thank you.
You’re welcome.
Hi Jason,
I read https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input, but am still not clear about the timesteps.
For example, I’m using every past 7 days’ data to predict today’s value (price).
Each day, there is one record of 6 features (Let’s call them feature1 – feature5, and price).
Suppose I have 1000 days of data.
Now I take [i:i+7] as my X, [i+7+1][price] as my y. Therefore, the shape of X is 993*7*6, the shape of y is 993.
Does the shape of X match [samples][timesteps][features]?
Or should I create 42 features in each row, e.g. t-1, t-2, …, t-7? then timesteps is 1, features is 42?
Yes, the first approach sounds reasonable. Although 1000 time steps is too many, consider reducing to 200-400.
Thanks for your reply.
What do you mean by reducing to 200-400? Do you mean 7 days’ data is too small? Perhaps I should use, for example, past 500 days’ data as my X?
Sorry, I meant perhaps change the framing of the problem to have a maximum of 200-400 time steps, which is reported to be a reasonable limit for LSTMs in practice.
Got it. Thank you.
You’re welcome!
How would you reshape your data to fit a 1D conv model? Is it the same as LSTM [samples, timesteps, features]?
Yes, the same!
Dear Jason.
My question is suppose I have a model lstm/dropout/LSTM/dropout/flatten/dense
then no. of hidden layers here will be 5 ie dropout/LSTM/dropout/flatten/dense
and if my data 2000 feature by 62 samples can I rehape it as 62,1,2000..
and what should be the no of Input lstm neurons/cells 2000 or not.
Regards Srirupa
Shape of the input is separate from the number of nodes in the LSTM layer.
The input shape must match the number of timesteps and features in your dataset:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Thank u Jason.
Now what should be the ans of this question
suppose I have a model lstm/dropout/LSTM/dropout/flatten/dense
then no. of hidden layers here will be 5 ie dropout/LSTM/dropout/flatten/dense
regards Srirupa
Only layers with weights are counted.
Jason..Thank u every time for you response.
Continuing the last query ..it means suppose I have lstm(128)/dropout(0.2)/lstm(64)/dropout(0.2)/flatten()/dense(1)..should there be 3 hidden layers excluding dropout and input lstm layer..
Please do reply..it is really helpful for me
Regards Srirupa
Dear Jason,does my above question make any sense or is it totally wrong
Regards Srirupa
You’re welcome.
That is how I would count.
Hi Jason,
I have n samples, each sample has 49 timesteps (past observations) and 2 features each (x and y coordinates). I want the network to learn the next timestep (50th), so that it can predict next x and y coordinate.I implemented a LSTM network but it is not learning. I think the problem comes from the shape of the output. Do I have to reshape my target set so that it has shape (n_samples, 2) or do I have to modify the output dense layer and set the layer size to 2 ? I do not understand how to tell my network that the output is 2D….
Yes, you can configure the model to have 2 output features, e.g. 2 nodes in the output layer.
That means the target for each sample will be a vector, not a value. e.g. the shape of y is [n, 2]
Hello Jason,
I am currently working with a LSTM architecture with some video skeleton data. I have prepared my data in the same way as above (multiple arrays, 144 features and varying number of frames for different video sequences). However, I am not too sure how I can reshape my training data for the input tensor. The question is that usually when you are dealing with video sequences that have different number of frames for different video samples, what would be an appropriate way to reshape the training data (video samples)? I was thinking since the input time steps are going to be fixed, maybe one way is to sample the same number of video frames for each video sequence, at the cost of losing some information. I would like to ask you opinion on this if possible. Many Thanks.
My takeaway from the idea described in the code above is that maybe the only way is to use the predefined input time steps to sample frames for each video sequence and start from there.
Yes, truncating/sampling to the same number of frames would be an easy first thing to try.
hi, Jason,
i am codeing about lstm model with keras recently, but i have some questions about the data shape. i have data like this:
[list([[1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8], [9, 10, 11, 3, 6, 5, 5, 4, 4, 12]])
list([[13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 1, 19], [16, 14, 18, 1, 20, 14, 21, 22]])
list([[1, 2, 23, 6, 24, 25, 7, 26, 27], [28, 28, 29, 30, 31, 23, 1, 4, 6, 7, 25, 26], [32, 29, 33, 34, 17, 33, 1, 23, 6, 7, 35, 26]])]
the first row/list, it is diagnoses about one patient, it consits of two visit, the first visit contains 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8 diagnose,the second visit contains 9,…,12 diagnose. For different patient, there is different visit times, and for each visit, there is different length of diagnose code.
How should i build a lstm model with this data? Looking forward to your replying!
I believe this will help with LSTM data shape:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hello Sir,
I am trying to train a lstm model with multiple time series of varying length. For purpose of training, I have segmented each clip with a window size of 25ms. For each such segment, I extract 5 features.
So, in summary #Samples = #Audio Clips, #Timesteps = #Segments (which varies for each file) and #Features = 5 (Fixed).
My Doubts:
1) Should I necessarily fix the #Timesteps by padding or dividing the longer files into smaller parts?
2) If it is not required, then in which data type should I arrange the 3D Input?
Also, are the samples i.e the segments are considered independent from each other, by the LSTM ?
The LSTM has memory/state across samples within a batch.
For variable length input, I would recommend padding to a fixed length and use a masking layer.
https://machinelearningmastery.com/data-preparation-variable-length-input-sequences-sequence-prediction/
Also, this will help with shaping the data:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hi, nice explanation, but I am struggling with a problem if we assume sample as 1, but my dependent variable has for example shape (50000,1) then how to reshape to match the sample dimension? I cannot change sample to 50000 as that would exceed the matrix integer values, please let me know what to do.
Good question, this will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hi. Jason . Thanks a lot.
I’m struggling with a problem, if I have the training set as [Samples=1 ,Timestep=6, Feature=6] and I put the lstm input shape as (Samples=1 ,Timestep=6, Feature=1), are the remaining features ignored or repeated until the 6th feature?
It will not let you reshape the data that way, an error will be thrown.
Hi Jason,thank you for this post. I’ve learned a lot from it.
I am confused with a problem.
My dataset is users’ daily measured value for each hour in a day. For example:
ID | 00:00 | 01:00 | … | 23:00
1 | v1 | v2 | … | v24
2 | v1 | v2 | … | v24
…
I am doing a time series classification.
If I want to use the hourly data, which are 24 values per day, to classify the ID, does the input shape will be like (sample number, 24, 1)?
Or it should be (sample number, 1, 24)?
I read most of the comment but a little confused. If the number of neuron is not relvent to input timestamp, is it mean that the network will feed the data according to timestamps?
For example, if timestamp is 24, and feature is 2, each rnn neuron will be feed 24 times, and 2 feature will be feed in each time?
Good question, this will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Nice post Jason. Thank you so much!
Thanks!
I have a question. What is the relation between data and its shape with the neural network. For instance if I have data with shape (45,1,700) How should the neural network be like for predicting output?
Good question, I answer it here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/how-many-layers-and-nodes-do-i-need-in-my-neural-network
Hi Jason,thank you for this post.
I am working on a text classification model, I use the Keras functional API, I want to concatenate the three flatten outputs of a CNN multi-channel for text (size (0.768) ) with an additional features vector that has 16 features for each word and next fed this vector to an LSTM network. I’m a bit confused about how to reshape this vector.
See this example:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/cnn-long-short-term-memory-networks/
goal is to train a model that can predict patient’s mortality based on four physiological measurements for 48 hours after admitting to ICU.
Description and Data
Link to download data: https://www.dropbox.com/s/si0acy6z67wk0y9/Midterm2.zip?dl=0
In train folder, you are given four csv files (Heart.csv, Temperature.csv, Respiration.csv, Glucose.csv) containing four physiological measurements for the same 2000 patients admitted to ICU in a hospital. Rows represents patients and the columns represent the physiological measurements of the patient taken hourly. There are 48 columns indicating the first 48 hours after the patient is admitted to ICU. 50% of patients survives the ICU and the remaining 50% die at some point after the first 48 hours.
The class labels are stored in y_train.csv (1: survives, 0: death). y_train.csv has only one column that indicates the class labels. Assume that order of patients in y_train.csv and the measurement csv files are same.
First, you need to load these four files to a numpy tensor x_train of shape (2000,48,4) which in the form of (# of training samples, # of time steps, # of features). Here # of time steps is 48 and # of features = 4 (four physiological metrics). This can be done in different ways. One way to do is to first create an empty x_train tensor of shape (2000,48,4). Load each of the csv file and simply copy data to x_train along the final axis. For example x_train[:,:,0] can store the heart measurements, x_train[:,:,0] can store the Temperature measurements and so on. Also, load class labels to y_train tensor of shape (2000,)
In test folder, you are also given four csv files (Heart.csv, Temperature.csv, Respiration.csv, Glucose.csv) containing four physiological measurements for the same test 400 patients. You will need to load these four files to x_test tensor of shape (400,48,4). The class labels are stored in y_test.csv (1: survives, 0: death). Also, load class labels to y_test tensor of shape (400,). y_test.csv has only one column that indicates the class labels. Assume that order of patients in y_test.csv and the measurement csv files are same.
Model:
Create a keras CNN model that contains the following layers
• 1D CNN layer
• ReLU activation layer.
• 1D MaxPooling layer of window size = 4, stride = 1.
• Flatten layer.
• Output Dense Layer with one node and sigmoid activation.
• Use binary cross entropy as the loss function
• Use early stopping criteria, with patience = 3.
Hyperparameter optimization
In the model above, perform hyperparameter optimization for the following hyperparameters. The different options for each hyperparameter to be explored are shown. Only one method of hyperparameter optimization is necessary.
• Kernel length = 3, 5.
• Number of kernels = 6, 32, 64, 92.
• Batch size = 20, 30, 50.
• Optimizers = Adam, SGD, RMSprop.
• Learning rate = 1*lr, 0.1*lr, 10*lr, where lr is the default learning rate of the optimizer in Keras.
Perhaps try some of the ideas here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/start-here/#better
Perhaps compare linear models?
Perhaps compare other machine learning models?
Perhaps try some of the ideas here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/machine-learning-performance-improvement-cheat-sheet/
Hey,
first of all all of your articles are very helpful, thanks!
I got the problem that eventhough reshape went fine I get an error that the test data does not fit to the train data considering the dimensions.
So I have a dataframe with [5000,140]. Trough split 80/20 I get train_data=(4000,140) and test_data=(1000,140). Trough reshaping, if I understood it correctly, this sould be train_data=(1,4000,140) and test_data=(1,1000,140) ?
Now even if the reshaping is correct, when running the autoencoder I get an error at validation_data, that time steps of train and test data is not equal but it mus be. What does that mean? How can I reshape the dimensions correctly so that this error does not occur?
The output shape for an autoencoder is different from other predictive models as you are trying to reconstruct the input, see this example:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/lstm-autoencoders/
Great post Jason. I have a question. My data set is 600 time-sequences of two features. So (600,2) dimensional array. I reshaped it as suggested by you to (1,600,2) or (3,200,2). This is my X_train. I’m not sure what my y_train should be?
As per the structure of LSTM, this must be a single value (for (1,600,2)) or 3 values (3,200,2). What exact values should there be in this array?
I am trying to develop a model to classify a given sequence of values. Would really appreciate any guidance.
The target (y) is the output of each sample that you want to predict or classify.
Thanks so much for your prompt response, Jason.
If I understand it correctly when my test data is (1,600,2), the y_train should be (1,) with the class label as an element. How should I handle this when I split this into (3,200,2) as you suggested?
My class labels wouldn’t work here because they stand for an entire class of 600 time steps.
I hope I have explained the scenario properly and looking forward to your response.
Not sure I follow, sorry.
Also, a dataset with just 1 or 3 samples does not sound reasonable for training a LSTM model.
greeting sir i am a computer science student and specialize in software engineering and i am currently working on my final year project. my project says that i’m supposed to predict the life cycle of a given polymer(until it ruptures) so in my dataset there is 3 colomns the force aplied to the polymer during a specific hours, it gives us the stress on the polymer so the outpute is one numirical value whice is the stress value (non_lineare regression) i tryed working with the CNN but i couldn’t so i’m trying to use the LSTM network but the structure of my data needs to split randomly as the train_test_split function do but every LSTM network I saw uses a manualy patern that allows the data to be splited sequencly so it’s easier to append the time sequence to the training and testing data so i’m wondering if the LSTM works fine for this regression probleme and a tutorial how to append the time sequence to the outpute variables of the train_test_split function (ndarrays) knowing that i tried to convert them to arrays and lists but unfortunately there is alyawes an error pops up i really need the answer, and sorry for my english it’s not my language thanks
LSTM assumes sequences of data, if you do not have sequences then it is not an appropriate method.
This tutorial will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/when-to-use-mlp-cnn-and-rnn-neural-networks/
thank you
You’re welcome.
Hello Jason and thanks for your support for all of us.
I am wondering if I can use LSTM to predict the outcome of the following situation.
I have the following dataset structure:
DVICE_NO MSE. CR. Age
————————————
3 13 0.1 70
1 26 0.5 67
2 … … …
. … … …
. … … …
1 20 0 87
3 26 1 66
2 12 1.2 90
3 27 1.8 88
The MSE ranges from 0 to 30 (0..30), the CR ranges from 0 to 5 (0..5) and the Age ranges from 30 to 45 (30..45).
As you can see, we have different rows regarding same device (for example in the table below we have three different readings regarding device#3). My goal s to use LSTM to predict the future reading for all the devices that we have in our dataset; in other word what is the MSE and CDR for device#3?
Can you please help me is this something applicable, is so, what data preparation I need to feed to LSTM.
Thanks in advance
LSTM might be appropriate, perhaps try it and compare results to other algorithms like MLP, CNN and other ML algorithms.
Sir,
I have a dataset of 444 rows and 81 columns ( features). I need to input this to LSTM. How do i convert this data to 3D data to input to LSTM model.
Kindly waiting for your reply.
Good question, this will show you how:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
Hi Jason,
I have a doubt. Is it possible that the dimension of input and output of a bidirectional RNN (GRU/LSTM)is equal?
Eg. If the input layer dimension is (128,16,128) followed by BiDirectional GRU with a hidden layer dimension of 32 and the output we get is also equal to Input i.e. (128,16,128) ??
You can design the model any way you like.
Hi Jason,
Thanks for the swift response. I tried but when I use 32 as hidden units in Bi-GRU I am getting output dimension as (None, 64,32) for input dimension (None, 64,16).
Perhaps an encoder-decoder type model would be more appropriate for you if you want to control the number of output steps of your model.
I am using the code as shown below:
output = Bidirectional(GRU(32, return_sequences=True), merge_mode=’mul’)(input)
hi
pls help me with following
import keras
from keras.models import Sequential
from keras.layers import LSTM, Dense, Dropout, LSTM
from keras.optimizers import Adam
import pandas as pd
#dataset import
dataset = pd.read_csv(‘C:\\Users\\Fatima\\Downloads\\train_subject1_raw01.csv’) #You need to change #directory accordingly
#print(dataset.head(10))
X = dataset.iloc[:,:32].values
y = dataset.iloc[:,32:33].values
#Normalizing the data
from sklearn.preprocessing import StandardScaler
sc = StandardScaler()
X = sc.fit_transform(X)
#print(X)
from sklearn.preprocessing import OneHotEncoder
ohe = OneHotEncoder()
y = ohe.fit_transform(y).toarray()
from sklearn.model_selection import train_test_split
X_train,X_test,y_train,y_test = train_test_split(X,y,test_size = 0.2)
print(“train size: {}”.format(X_train.shape))
print(“train Label size: {}”.format(y_train.shape))
print(“test size: {}”.format(X_test.shape))
print(“test Label size: {}”.format(y_test.shape))
X_train = X_train.reshape(1, 97893, 32)
y_train = y_train.reshape(1,97893 ,3)
X_test = X_test.reshape(1,24474,32)
y_test = y_test.reshape(1,24474,3)
print(“train size: {}”.format(X_train.shape))
print(“train Label size: {}”.format(y_train.shape))
print(“test size: {}”.format(X_test.shape))
print(“test Label size: {}”.format(y_test.shape))
#Initializing the classifier Network
classifier = Sequential()
classifier.add(LSTM(128, input_shape=(X_train.shape[1:]), return_sequences=True))
classifier.add(Dropout(0.2))
#Adding a second LSTM network layer
classifier.add(LSTM(128))
#Adding a dense hidden layer
classifier.add(Dense(64, activation=’relu’))
classifier.add(Dropout(0.2))
#Adding the output layer
classifier.add(Dense(3, activation=’softmax’))
#Compiling the network
classifier.compile( loss=’categorical_crossentropy’,
optimizer=Adam(lr=0.001, decay=1e-6),
metrics=[‘accuracy’] )
print(classifier.summary())
#Fitting the data to the model
#classifier.fit(X_train, y_train,epochs=3,validation_data=(X_test, y_test))
print(“train size: {}”.format(X_train.shape))
print(“train Label size: {}”.format(y_train.shape))
print(“test size: {}”.format(X_test.shape))
print(“test Label size: {}”.format(y_test.shape))
classifier.fit(X_train, y_train, batch_size =batch_size, epochs = 1, verbose = 5)
test_loss, test_acc = classifier.evaluate(X_test, y_test)
print(‘Test Loss: {}’.format(test_loss))
print(‘Test Accuracy: {}’.format(test_acc))
error at
classifier.fit(X_train, y_train, batch_size =64, epochs = 1, verbose = 5)
ValueError: Shapes (None, 97893, 3) and (None, 3) are incompatible
This is a common question that I answer here:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/can-you-read-review-or-debug-my-code
hi jason
please help me with the codes.
#Import the libraries
import math
from math import sqrt
import numpy as np
from numpy import concatenate
import pandas as pd
from pandas import DataFrame
from pandas import concat
from pandas import read_csv
from sklearn.preprocessing import MinMaxScaler
#from sklearn.preprocessing import LabelEncoder
from sklearn.metrics import mean_squared_error
from keras.models import Sequential
from keras.layers import Dense, LSTM
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
from matplotlib import pyplot
#plt.style.use(‘fivethirtyeight’)
# load dataset
dataset = read_csv(‘feature5_ctu_nil_targ.csv’, header=0, index_col=0)
values = dataset.values
print(dataset.shape)
# ensure all data is float
values = values.astype(‘float32′)
# normalize features
scaler = MinMaxScaler(feature_range=(0, 1))
scaled = scaler.fit_transform(values)
# split the dataset into 75/25 for train and test
training_dataset_length = math.ceil(len(dataset) * .75)
print(training_dataset_length)
train = values[:training_dataset_length, :]
test = values[training_dataset_length:, :]
# split into input and outputs
train_X, train_y = train[:, :-1], train[:, -1]
test_X, test_y = test[:, :-1], test[:, -1]
# reshape input to be 3D [samples, timesteps, features]
#n_features=5
train_X = np.reshape(train_X, (train_X.shape[0], 1, train_X.shape[1]))
#train_X = train_X.reshape((train_X.shape[0], 1, train_X.shape[1]))
#train_y = train_y.reshape((train_y.shape[0], 1, train_y.shape[1]))
test_X = test_X.reshape((test_X.shape[0], 1, test_X.shape[1]))
#test_X = np.reshape(test_X (test_X.shape[0], 1, test_X.shape[1]))
#test_y = test_y.reshape((test_y.shape[0], 1, test_y.shape[1]))
print(train_X.shape, train_y.shape, test_X.shape, test_y.shape)
#print(train_y.shape)
# design network
model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(50, return_sequences=True, input_shape=(train_X.shape[1], train_X.shape[2])))
model.add(LSTM(units=30, return_sequences=True))
model.add(LSTM(units=30))
model.add(Dense(units=1))
model.compile(loss=’mae’, optimizer=’adam’)
model.summary()
# fit network
history = model.fit(train_X, train_y, epochs=10, batch_size=50, validation_data=(test_X, test_y), verbose=2, shuffle=False)
# plot history
”’pyplot.plot(history.history[‘loss’], label=’train’)
pyplot.plot(history.history[‘val_loss’], label=’test’)
pyplot.legend()
pyplot.show()”’
”’#check predicted values
predictions = model.predict(test_X)
#Undo scaling
predictions = scaler.inverse_transform(predictions)
#Calculate RMSE score
rmse=np.sqrt(np.mean(((predictions- test_y)**2)))
print(rmse)”’
# make a prediction
yhat = model.predict(test_X)
test_X = test_X.reshape((test_X.shape[0], test_X.shape[2]))
# invert scaling for forecast
inv_yhat = concatenate((yhat, test_X[:, 1:]), axis=1)
inv_yhat = scaler.inverse_transform(inv_yhat)
inv_yhat = inv_yhat[:,0]
# invert scaling for actual
test_y = test_y.reshape((len(test_y), 1))
inv_y = concatenate((test_y, test_X[:, 1:]), axis=1)
inv_y = scaler.inverse_transform(inv_y)
inv_y = inv_y[:,0]
# calculate RMSE
rmse = sqrt(mean_squared_error(inv_y, inv_yhat))
print(‘Test RMSE: %.3f’ % rmse)
ValueError: operands could not be broadcast together with shapes (81367,3) (4,) (81367,3)
Perhaps these tips will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/can-you-read-review-or-debug-my-code
Hi Jason,
Thank you for your great post. I have a dataset of 5000 patients. For each patient, a biosignal has been recorded for 60 seconds with a frequency of 80Hz, i.e. I have 5000 univariate samples with each sample containing 4800 data points. I want to classify my time series into two categories (mortality vs. non-mortality). If I want to use LSTMs or CNNs for classification, could you please let me know how I should structure X_train and what the input_shape looks like? As far as I’ve understood, the time step should be between 200-400 for LSTMs. Let’s say I pick 200. Is either of these two situations correct?
1) Do I have to split each signal into 200 segments? Since each segment would have 24 data points (4800/200 = 24), do I have to convert each segment to a single number (for example by averaging the 24 values)? Is it correct to say that:
X_train = (5000, 200)
input_shape = (5000, 200, 1)?
2) Do I have to divide each patient’s signal into 24 samples (with each sample containing 200 datapoints)? Is it correct to say that:
X_train = (24*5000, 200)
input_shape = (24*5000, 200, 1)?
I would appreciate your help.
Perhaps these tips will help:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/faq/single-faq/what-is-the-difference-between-samples-timesteps-and-features-for-lstm-input
I try to avoid being perspective as there is no single best way to frame a prediction problem. Instead, try a few different framings for your data and discover what works well or best.
hi jason
Could you be Input input layer not first hidden layer ?
thanks
No input layer is not a hidden layer.
Hello Jason thank you for the tutorial on LSTM.
I tried to apply the concepts on pretty simple example.
I got the close price of a stock for 5 years (i.e 1500 values) , and try to predict the close price of stock for the day after
I’d like to take into consideration 10 previous samples in order to predict the next day.
So the time series is one feature and the Y( the target) is the same time series shifted by one day
X= [2.376227, 2.376227, 2.360171, …, 4.983 , 4.973 , 5.004 ]
Y= [ 2.376227, 2.360171, …, 4.983 , 4.973 , 5.004 ]
Then after have normalized both and split between training and test
X_scaled, Y_scaled X_scaled_train, Y_scaled_train
Now I have to reshape the X_scaled_train before passing it to the LSTM, but not the Y_scaled_train (correct?)
….
The input to every LSTM layer must be three-dimensional.
The three dimensions of this input are:
• Samples. One sequence is one sample. A batch is comprised of one or more samples.
• Time Steps. One time step is one point of observation in the sample.
• Features. One feature is one observation at a time step.
….
In this case 1500 samples should be reshaped to 150 (1500/10)
X_scaled_train = np.reshape(X_scaled_train, (150, 10, 1))
Build the model
1
2
3 model = Sequential()
model.add(LSTM(32, input_shape=(10, 1)))
model.add(Dense(1))
optimizer = tf.keras.optimizers.Adam(learning_rate=2e-04)
model.compile(loss=tf.keras.losses.Huber(),optimizer=optimizer,metrics=[“mae”])
…..
Fit the model
history = model.fit(X_scaled_train,y_scaled_train,epochs=100,batch_size = 1,callbacks = [early_stopping])
Could you please tell whether the procedure is correct?
Thanks a lot.
Sorry, it is too long for me to read. Can you try this out and see if the result fits your expectation?
Hi Jason! Thank you for your work!! I have a question: In my work I have a dataframe in which each line has a patient record over the years and each column is a feature. The output is 0 or 1, depending on whether the patient has the disease or not.
Example for 2 years with 5 features: X is [[1 2 3 4 5], [1 3 5 6 4]] and the output [0 1]
My goal is through an LSTM to be able to predict whether a next patient will have the disease or not, but I don’t understand how I should reshape the data. For 10 years and 5 features, I have a y with 10 values (one for each year) and should I put the X in what shape?
I think this post can give you some idea: https://machinelearningmastery.com/how-to-develop-lstm-models-for-time-series-forecasting/
Pay attention to the n_steps (number of time steps) and n_features
Hello Jason, thank you for the awesome tutorials.
You have a tutorial about Human Activity Recognition with LSTM. In that example, the input shape is (128,9). It means 128 time steps and 9 features. Also the batch size equals 64. As far as I understood, it indicates that in each process, 64 samples are fed to the network, and each sample contains 128 time steps and 9 features. Am I right?
In that tutorial, it is mentioned that there is a 50% overlap window because 128/64 = 2. I am confused about the meaning of overlap here. When in each process 64 samples are fed into the layer, how window overlapping occurs?
Thanks again for your time.
You’re right on the batch.
Overlap is a concept specific to time series. Imagine you have time 1, 2, 3, etc. And you have a window of size 10. Obviously the first window of data is 1 to 10, but what about second window of data? In case of 50% overlap, that is 6 to 15. In case of 0% overlap, you use 11 to 20.
Hi Jason
I changed the code to compatible with my data,( a csv file with 405-time step and 920 feature)
when I run the code I after epoc 1 the loss is nan and the output vector is completely nan
I have tested it for a small file (csv file with 405 timesteps and 4 features) it correctly works.
can you help me if it is possible?
Dear Dr Jason,
Thank you for your tutorial.
The input data to the LSTM model is 3D as in the simple example
The array is shaped in the form of:
number of samples = batch size = 1
number of time steps = number of rows = 10
number of features = number of columns = 1
Questions for clarification:
(1)number of samples = batch size = 1 – is that a one step ahead prediction:?
if
2(a) number of samples = batch size =2 is that 2 steps ahead prediction?
2(b) Can we predict one step ahead even though batch size = 2?
2(c) Setting a model,with batch_size >= 2 – input_shape for LSTM 3 parameters.
model.add(LSTM(32, input_shape=(2, 10, 1)))
Thank you,
Anthony of Sydney
The batch size here should be how much your LSTM should remember in the hidden layer. You always get one step ahead prediction but the batch size tells when you should reset the hidden state.
Dear Jason and Team,
Thanks so much for all this content, it is the web I have seen on the internet.
I have a question regarding a problem I want to solve. I have a signal (voltage along time) with periodicity, and I want to detect with a neural network when this period decreases a certain percentage so I can activate an actuator (on-off actuator). I have read your book about LSTMs, and I think that I can use a Sequence Classification LSTM arquitecture. Does this makes sense?
Also I don’t know how to prepare the data for the x and y inputs of the fitting model. My guess is that x would be the voltage along time, and y would be the booelan values of this actuator (i.e. when the period decreases). Is this correct?.
Thanks a lot and greetings from Spain!
Hi Miguel…The following resource may be of interest to you:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/how-to-develop-lstm-models-for-multi-step-time-series-forecasting-of-household-power-consumption/
Hello. I have a problem related to those things. I have sequential data and every input of one sample composed of 4 different time series. As an output, I have one time series for each sample that having same length with the inputs. When I rearranging the matrices, naturally input have 4x rows than the output. And keras gave the error “ValueError: Data cardinality is ambiguous:
x sizes: 504
y sizes: 126
Make sure all arrays contain the same number of samples.”
How can i solve this problem? Row number must be same but i have 4 input rows and one output row for every sample.
Thanks.
Hi Omer…The following discussion may be of interest to you:
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/62253289/valueerror-data-cardinality-is-ambiguous
Goodmorning sir, thank you for your explanation.
My questione Is: how to treat with more than One sample with different timestep each? Should I reshape them? And then, what It I apply the model on Real Life? Does the length of timestep must match or It’s Just a training problem?
Hi Alessia…The following resource may be of interest:
https://machinelearningmastery.com/use-timesteps-lstm-networks-time-series-forecasting/
Thank you very much.
In addition, what function or procedement should I use to concatenate each sample and reshape the array?
Hi
Is correct use: data = data.reshape(-1, 10, 2) too ?
Dear Dr. Jason,
I’ve beeing using your examples and explanations on my learnings and job activities.
I have a question regarding the shape, that’s why I came back to the basics, but I still didn’t find my answer and would like to share my example.
I have a Multi-Channel Multi Step Input
( 1000 samples , 20 timesteps, 4 features).
While training this 3D Input with LSTM and CNN it works fine, but I was wondering if I could improve the speed and spare some resources of my modell, since 3 of these features doesn’t change inside the sample.
imagine that just the first feature is changing ( curve) (like a sinus curve with noise) during all 20 timesteps, but all other 3 features are relative constant ( Temperature, Pressure, Humidity).
curve = [0,18,36,54,72 …. 344]
feature_temp = [10,10,10,10,11…10]
feature_press = [990,991,991,991,….,991]
feature_humidity = [60,60,60,60…..60]
I was wondering:
Is there anyway to feed a modell with an mixed Input (1000,20,1) and (1000,1,3)? I would like to feed the curve and the mean of the features.
I was wondering if I could just add the mean of the features as last timesteps for each curve, but I’m affraid it’s not the real approach.
Thank you very much for your courses, books, blog entries and of course for a reply
Hi M. Ramos…The following resource may be of interest:
https://www.kaggle.com/code/shivajbd/input-and-output-shape-in-lstm-keras